Table 1.
Reported genotoxic events in HSC gene therapy clinical trials
Diseases | Patients | Vector backbone |
Transgene | Follow-up | Severe adverse effects |
Insertion sites (clonal dominance) |
Clinical outcome |
References | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SCID-X1 | 9 | MFG | γC | 9 years | T-ALL | No.1 | LMO2 | Died despite chemotherapy | [1,2,10,15] |
γ-retroviral | (range, 8 to 11) | in four patients | No.2 | LMO2 | Remission with chemotherapy | ||||
vector | No.3 | CCND2 | Remission with chemotherapy | ||||||
No.4 | LMO2, BMI1 | Remission with chemotherapy | |||||||
Other 5 | No clonal dominance | Alive, improved immune function | |||||||
SCID-X1 | 10 | MFG | γC | 5 years | T-ALL | No.1 | LMO2 | Remission with chemotherapy | [14,16] |
γ-retroviral | in one patient | Other 9 | No clonal dominance | Alive with improved immune | |||||
vector | function | ||||||||
ADA-SCID | 10 | GIADAl | ADA | 4.0 years | None | Integration hotspots near | All alive with improved | [3,4] | |
MLV-based | (range, | DYRK1A,BLM,LMO2, | immune and metabolic | ||||||
retroviral vector | 1.8 to 8.0) | CCND2 and BCL2 no clonal | parameters | ||||||
selection ) | |||||||||
X-CGD | 2 | pSF7, SFFV- | gp91phox | 4 years | MDS | No.1 | MDS1/Evi1, PRDM16, and | Died from sepsis | [5,9] |
based retrovirus | SETBP1 | 27 months | |||||||
vector | MDS | No.2 | MDS1/Evi1, PRDM16, and | Underwent an allogeneic | |||||
SETBP1 | HSC transplantation at month 45 | ||||||||
X-CGD | 3 | MFGS | gp91phox | 3 years | None | No clonal dominance | Clinical improvement | [6] | |
retroviral vector | |||||||||
X-ALD | 2 | HIV-1-derived | ABCD1 | 24 to 30 months | None | No clonal dominance | Alive with decreased progression | [7] | |
lentiviral vector | of neurologic phenotype | ||||||||
β-thalassemia | 1 | HIV-1-derived | β-globin | 33 months | None | Dominant HMGA2 expression | Alive and transfusion- | [26] | |
lentiviral vector | clone | independent | |||||||
WAS | 2 | CMMP | WASP | 3 years | T-ALL in one | LMO2, CCND2, and BMI1 | T-ALL patient with ongoing | [8] | |
retroviral vector | patient(LMO2) | in T-cells, and MDS1 | chemotherapy, the other alive | ||||||
/EVI1, PRDM16, and | with improved immune | ||||||||
SETBP1 in granulocytes | function and decreased cytopenias |