Skip to main content
. 2012 Nov 28;7(11):e49802. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0049802

Table 1. Carbon and nitrogen isotope values from bone collagen of Mediterranean late Upper Palaeolithic (17–11 ka cal BP) and Mesolithic (10-8 ka cal BP) humans.

Period Site Individuals δ13C (‰) δ15N (‰) Source
Upp. Pal. Grotta d’Oriente (Sicily) Oriente C −19.3 11.0 [14]
Upp. Pal. Grotta Addaura Caprara (Sicily) Addaura 1 −19.7 9.6 [8], [9]
Upp. Pal. Grotta di San Teodoro (Sicily) 3 −19.7±0.4 12.0±0.4 [8]
Upp. Pal. Grotta del Romito (Italy) 8 −19.5±0.3 10.1±1.1 [14]
Upp. Pal. Arene Candide (Italy) 2 −19.5±0.8 9.0±0.1 [5]
Mesolithic Grotta d’Oriente (Sicily) 2 −18.4±0.8 11.0±0.5 this study
Mesolithic Grotta Addaura Caprara (Sicily) 2 −19.5±0.2 9.2±0.7 [9]
Mesolithic Grotta Molara (Sicily) 2 −19.9±0.5 8.8±2.3 [9]
Mesolithic Grotta dell’Uzzo (Sicily) 2 −21.0±0.0* 10.6±0.2* [5]
Mesolithic El Collado (Spain) 9 −18.3±0.7 10.3±1.2 [10]
Mesolithic Vela Spilja – Vela Luka (Croatia) 4 −18.6±0.6 9.2±1.0 [7]
Mesolithic Pupićina Cave (Croatia) 2 −19.2±0.1 10.5±0.3 [7]
Mesolithic Pupićina Cave (Croatia) 4 −19.3** 10.6** [6]
Mesolithic Monte Leone (Corsica) 1 −18.0 9.9 [11]
Mesolithic Araguina Sennola (Corsica) 1 −18.8 10.6 [11]

(*)the C/N ratios of the human bone collagen from Grotta dell’Uzzo are at the limit for well-preserved collagen ( = 3.6). In the absence of other published data on the quality of the collagen (%C, %N, %yield) analysed by Francalacci [5], the isotope ratios of these individuals should be considered with caution. The low δ13C values might, in fact, be due to contamination.

(**)the standard deviation could not be calculated because the raw data was not published by Paine et al. [6].