Table 1.
Scenario summary | Manifestations | Effect of ERT | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Physical | Intellectual | Physical | Life expectancy | Intellectual | ||
1a | 11-year old with severe physical MPSVI and normal intellect, ERT will prolong life | Severe | Nil | Significant improvement | Increased | Nil improvement |
2a | MPSI-S with minor health issues as an adult but normal intellect, ERT will only improve health issues a little | Mild | Nil | Minimal improvement | Unchanged | Nil improvement |
3a | Severe physical and intellectual manifestations of MPSII. Death in 5 years without ERT | Severe | Severe | Minimal improvement | Increased 3 years | Nil improvement |
4a | The 1-year-old younger brother of the MPSII patient in 3a. ERT will prolong his life but not halt the CNS manifestations | Moderate | Severe | Minimal improvement | Increased 15 years | Nil improvement |
5a | Mild MPSII with early joint and mobility difficulties, and mild school performance issues | Mild | Mild | Moderate improvement | Not significant | Nil improvement |
3b | –a | Severe | Severe | Minimal improvement | Increased 3 years | Significant improvement |
4b | –a | Moderate | Severe | Minimal improvement | Increased 15 years | Significant improvement |
5b | –a | Mild | Mild | Moderate improvement | Unchanged | Significant improvement |
a3b, 4b, and 5b are identical to 3a, 4a, and 5a; however, the respondents were asked to consider whether they would use ERT for the patients in 3a, 4a, and 5a if it improved the CNS manifestations