Skip to main content
. 2012 Nov 29;7(11):e50725. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0050725

Table 2. Effects of nodule size on the diagnostic performance of different US parameters and Q-USE in the diagnosis of cytologically indeterminate (Thy 3) thyroid follicular lesions.

Major diameter <1 cm (n = 32)
Malignantnodules Benignnodules Sensitivity Specificity NPV PPV Accuracy OR p value
Echogenicity
Ipoechoic/mixed 11 10 91.7 50.0 90.9 52.4 70.8 11.0 0.016
Others 1 10 (61.5–99.8) (27.2–72.8) (58.7–99.8) (29.8–74.3) (56.9–84.7) (1.46-nd)
Microcalcifications
Present 8 8 66.7 60.0 75.0 50.0 63.3 3.0 0.144
Absent 4 12 (34.9–90.1) (36.1–80.9) (47.6–92.7) (24.7–75.3) (45.6–81.1) (0.7–12.8)
Irregular margins
Present 12 0 100 100 100 100 100 nd <0.001
Absent 0 20 (73.5–100) (83.2–100) (83.2–100) (73.5–100) (100–100) nd
Strain ratio
<2.05 1 16 91.7 80.0 94.1 73.3 85.8 44.0 <0.001
>2.05 11 4 (61.5–99.8) (56.3–94.3) (71.3–99.9) (44.9–92.2) (73.7–98.0) (5.2-nd)
Major diameter >1 cm (n = 108)
Echogenicity
Ipoechoic or mixed 20 33 71.4 58.8 85.5 37.7 65.1 3.6 0.006
Others 8 47 (51.3–86.8) (47.2–69.6) (73.3–93.5) (24.8–52.1) (55.0–75.2) (1.4–8.9)
Microcalcifications
Present 12 28 42.9 65.0 76.5 30.0 53.9 1.4 0.459
Absent 16 52 (24.5–62.8) (53.5–75.3) (64.6–85.9) (16.6–46.5) (43.2–64.6) (0.6–3.3)
Irregular margins
Present 16 8 57.1 90.0 85.7 66.7 73.6 12.0 <0.001
Absent 12 72 (37.2–75.5) (81.2–95.6) (76.4–92.4) (44.7–84.4) (63.7–83.5) (4.3–33.6)
Strain ratio
<2 4 76 85.7 95.0 95.0 85.7 90.4 114.0 <0.001
>2 24 4 (67.9–96.0) (87.7–98.6) (87.7–98.6) (67.3–96.0) (83.3–97.4) (27.3–476.0)

NPV, negative predictive value; PPV, positive predictive value; OR, odds ratio. In brackets the 95% confidence interval. nd, non-determinable.