Skip to main content
. 2012 Nov 29;7(11):e48921. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0048921

Table 3. Symptom prevalence of the diary panel sub-cohort, by zone and year (n = 380)a.

Reduced exposure zone Increased exposure zoneb Eastern stack zoneb Control zone
2006 2007 2008 2006 2007 2008 2006 2007 2008 2006 2007 2008
N c (% of 2006) 86 76 (88) 70 (81) 82 57 (70) 52 (63) 85 69 (81) 62 (73) 81 57 (70) 46 (57)
%
Symptom days d
At least once 99 96 94 96 93 98 95 97 94 94 91 98
10% of days 93 84 79 89 70 77 82 78 89 84 72 76
>20% of days 69 67 60 73 53 62 62 64 66 63 60 61
Day-time symptoms d
At least once 79 72 70 84 70 69 67 65 63 63 58 65
>10% of days 52 43 53 63 42 48 49 46 48 41 40 43
>20% of days 36 33 37 39 26 37 33 32 31 23 25 30
Night-time symptoms d
At least once 64 61 59 73 44 50 66 59 65 54 42 52
>10% of days 36 30 27 38 25 29 34 32 40 30 26 28
>20% of days 19 13 13 21 12 15 18 22 21 15 19 17
Wheeze d
At least once 28 24 20 35 21 23 22 28 35 35 28 33
>10% of days 9 7 9 17 4 10 11 9 5 15 14 7
>20% of days 3 7 3 10 4 4 6 4 0 11 9 4
Bronchodilator use d
At least once 12 16 10 21 11 12 6 7 8 12 12 13
>10% of days 3 7 6 12 7 10 2 3 2 6 11 4
>20% of days 2 1 1 5 5 4 0 0 0 5 9 4
Cough d
At least once 71 68 60 77 53 56 66 64 58 57 46 63
>10% of days 43 33 39 48 32 35 40 38 45 36 32 37
>20% of days 26 18 23 32 12 21 21 23 26 20 25 30
Upper resp. symptoms d
At least once 50 50 53 60 44 44 48 49 53 40 44 50
>10% of days 19 17 29 24 11 21 18 23 18 9 14 26
>20% of days 5 8 13 12 7 10 6 9 3 5 11 15
Lower resp symptomse f 37 44 33 26 57 51 38 32 44 31 38 39
Severe lower resp sympe f 6 7 8 12 16 13 5 7 6 9 7 12
Upper resp. symptoms e f 12 18 18 5 27 33 11 22 15 8 26 20
Mouth symptoms f 12 14 22 9 18 15 7 22 21 8 14 9
a

Each subject contributed up to 63 days of data in the diary study.

b

Participants in overlapping area of increased exposure zone and stack zone, diary panel cohort (2006 = 6(4); 2007 = 5(2); 2008 = 5(3)), contributed data to both zones. n =  subjects in overlapping area with spirometry; (n) = subjects in overlapping area taking part in peak flow and symptom diary.

c

Panel sub-cohort participants who took part in peak flow/symptom diary.

d

Symptoms recorded by diary. % represents proportion of subjects experiencing those symptoms a) at least one day during the study period; b) >10% of days during the study period; c) >20% of days during the study period.

e

Composite variables derived from variables measured in questionnaire (See Table S1, Supporting Information).

f

Attributes measured by questionnaire.