Skip to main content
. 2012 Dec 5;7(12):e50251. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0050251

Table 2. Quality Assessment.

Study/Quality Scale Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8 Overall Rating
Antoniou, 2000 I I II II II II II I ***
Asch, 2002 II II II III II II I III **
Atlas, 2009 III II II II II II II III **
Balyk, 2008 II II I II II I III II ***
Barrett, 2001 II II II III III II II I **
Buckley, 2002 III II II III III II II II **
Deustsch, 2006 II II II IIII III III III III *
Glowacki, 1997 III II II IIII III IIII III II *
Greenough, 1994 II II II III II III II II **
Henn III, 2008 III II II I I II II II ***
Johannsen, 1997 II II II II III II II II **
Lin, 2000 II II II III III III II II *
MacKay, 1995 II II II III III IIII III III *
McKee, 2000 II II II II III II III II **
Nagle, 1994 II II II III IIII III III II *
Nicholson, 2003 II II II II II II II I ***
Rosenberger, 2008 I II II III II II II I ***
Spangehl, 2002 I II II II II I III II ***
Straub, 1999 III II II IIII III III II IIII *
Westkaemper, 1998 II II I IIII II II II II **