Skip to main content
. 2012 Dec 27;7(12):e50196. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0050196

Table 4. Summary of major errors in previously reported mass changes. Calculated values seen in this table are based on calculations made in this study.

Reported uterin egg mass Reported near full- term embryo mass Percentage Change Percentage Difference
Species Study Name Author Mass Reported Calculated
Scyliorhinus canicula Scyllium canicula Ranzi 1932 Dry 0.627 0.538 -14.195 20.46
Needham 1942 Dry 0.620 a 0.550 a -11.290 20.46
Mustelus antarcticus Ranzi 1936 Dry 2.300 2.400 4.348 100
Needham 1942 Dry 2.300 2.500 a 8.696 100
Scoliodon laticaudus Wourms et al. 1988 Dry 0.00007 0.900 1000000 a 1285614.286 22.22
Centroscymnus coelolepis Moura et al. 2011 Water 47.04 78.09 95.22 b 66.01 44.25
Squalus blainvillei Acanthias blainvillei Needham 1942 Water 8.400 17.900 88 b 113.10 22.19
Squalus blainvillei Acanthias blainvillei Needham 1942 Inorganic 0.200 1.800 1250 b 800.00 56.25
Mustelus antarcticus Needham 1942 Water 2.100 29.800 1480 b 1319.05 12.20
Mustelus antarcticus Storrie et al. 2009 Dry 2.267 17.775 784 b 684.08 14.61
Dalatias licha Scymnus lichia Needham 1942 Inorganic 2.000 8.000 30 c 300.00 90.00
Carcharias taurus Eugomphodus taurus Wourms 1993 Dry 120000 c 1177814.11 89.81
Mustelus vulgaris Ranzi 1932 Inorganic 0.050 1.450 2800.000 94.16
Ranzi 1936 Inorganic 0.550 c 1.450 163.636 94.16
Mustelus mustelus Mustelus laevis Ranzi 1932 Inorganic 0.069 5.320 7610.145 91.18
Ranzi 1936 Inorganic 0.690 c 5.320 671.014 91.18
Mustelus antarcticus Ranzi 1934 Wet 4.400 35.200 700.000 9.74
Ranzi 1936 Wet 4.400 32.200 d 631.818 9.74
Squalus blainvillei Acanthias blainvillei Ranzi 1932 Wet 19.260 38.830 101.610 47.32
Ranzi 1936 Wet 19.260 29.570 d 53.531 47.32
a

 =  Rounding.

c

 =  Typographical error.

b

 =  Miscalculation.

d

 =  Discrepancy.