Table 2. Resistance mechanisms, patterns of inheritance, evolutionary origins and prevalence of mutations conferring insecticide resistance.
Species | Mechanism | Gene | Pattern of Inheritance | Evolutionary Origin | Citation |
Anopheles gambiae | Target Site Insensitivity | Vssc | Recessive | Multiple | [44] |
Bemisia tabaci | Target Site Insensitivity | Vssc | Recessive | Multiple* | [7] |
Leptinotarsa decemlineata | Target Site Insensitivity | Vssc | Recessive | Multiple | Rinkevich et al, Submitted |
Musca domestica | Target Site Insensitivity | Vssc | Recessive | Multiple | [5] and this paper |
Myzus persicae and Myzus nicotinae | Target Site Insensitivity | Vssc | Recessive | Multiple | [6] |
Culex pipiens | Enhanced Detoxification | Esterase B | Completely Dominant | Single | [11] |
Drosophila melanogaster | Enhanced Detoxification | CYP6G1 | Dominant | Single | [10] |
Musca domestica | Enhanced Detoxification | CYP6D1 | Dominant | Single | [5] |
Myzus persicae | Enhanced Detoxification | E4 and FE4 | Dominant | Single | [12] |
Lucilia cuprina | Enhanced detoxification | LcαE7 (G137D) | Incompletely Dominant | Single* | [9] |
Lucilia cuprina | Enhanced detoxification | LcαE7 (T251L) | Incompletely Dominant | Multiple | [9] |
Bemisia tabaci(B-biotype) | Target Site Insensitivity | Rdl | Incompletely Dominant | Single | [8] |
Bemisia tabaci(non B-biotype) | Target Site Insensitivity | Rdl | Incompletely Dominant | Multiple∧ | [8] |
Drosophila melanogaster | Target Site Insensitivity | Rdl | Incompletely Dominant | Single | [16] |
Drosophila simulans | Target Site Insensitivity | Rdl | Incompletely Dominant | Multiple | [45] |
Tribolium castaneum | Target Site Insensitivity | Rdl | Incompletely Dominant | Multiple | [33] |
“While phylogenetic analysis of these haplotypes suggests that the Asp137 and Leu251 mutations each arose at least twice, evidence for recombination was detected across the region, therefore single origins for these resistance mutations cannot be ruled out.” [9].
∧The number of species/subspecies of B. tabaci has recently been questioned [46]. If the results above are from different species then findings of multiple origins of resistance need to be interpreted with care.