Table 1.
Acupuncture | Tactile | ||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Subjects no. | Num. of activations | Num. of deactivations | Subjects no. | Num. of activations | Num. of deactivations | ||||||||||
NO PSGS | PSGS | ∆ | NO PSGS | PSGS | ∆ | NO PSGS | PSGS | ∆ | NO PSGS | PSGS | ∆ | ||||
Sub01 | 5955 | 3859 | −35% | 2418 | 2258 | -7% | Sub01 | 137 | 493 | 260% | 1858 | 776 | −58% | ||
Sub02 | 5331 | 4335 | −19% | 1224 | 3183 | 160% | Sub02 | 1011 | 4591 | 354% | 3763 | 2024 | −46% | ||
Sub03 | 8858 | 1681 | −81% | 23 | 7094 | 30743% | Sub03 | 5458 | 2861 | −48% | 119 | 2089 | 1655% | ||
Sub04 | 2067 | 2056 | −1% | 8 | 48 | 500% | Sub04 | 4598 | 2929 | −36% | 122 | 1269 | 940% | ||
Sub05 | 1514 | 882 | −42% | 15 | 516 | 3340% | Sub05 | 669 | 1160 | 73% | 391 | 285 | −27% | ||
Sub06 | 1 | 31 | 3000% | 407 | 112 | −72% | Sub06 | 3028 | 2299 | −24% | 634 | 1480 | 133% | ||
Sub07 | 429 | 426 | −1% | 933 | 666 | −29% | Sub07 | 556 | 1506 | 171% | 2005 | 1964 | −2% | ||
Sub08 | 8109 | 2422 | −70% | 18 | 2430 | 13400% | Sub08 | 10999 | 3706 | −66% | 49 | 10182 | 20680% | ||
Sub09 | 640 | 1017 | 59% | 61 | 71 | 16% | Sub09 | 7024 | 5328 | −24% | 2556 | 5031 | 97% | ||
Sub10 | 9388 | 3007 | −68% | 3095 | 9423 | 204% | Sub10 | 2294 | 917 | −60% | 1 | 527 | 52600% | ||
Sub11 | 1588 | 1191 | −25% | 447 | 924 | 107% | Sub11 | 5969 | 5084 | −15% | 2746 | 4033 | 47% | ||
Sub12 | 3866 | 5659 | 46% | 2090 | 3682 | 76% | Sub12 | 1854 | 1528 | −18% | 11 | 462 | 4100% | ||
Sub13 | 39 | 6694 | 17064% | 13037 | 2450 | −81% | Sub13 | 546 | 499 | −9% | 19 | 75 | 295% | ||
Sub14 | 228 | 896 | 293% | 7 | 20 | 186% | Sub14 | 151 | 1306 | 765% | 2027 | 1446 | −29% | ||
Sub15 | 5261 | 1849 | −65% | 381 | 1260 | 231% | Sub15 | 2200 | 685 | −69% | 26 | 164 | 531% | ||
Sub16 | 278 | 358 | 29% | 583 | 441 | −24% | Sub16 | 9497 | 3009 | −68% | 813 | 3679 | 353% | ||
Sub17 | 1043 | 693 | −34% | 138 | 574 | 316% | Sub17 | 1562 | 908 | −42% | 268 | 674 | 151% | ||
Sub18 | 5043 | 1906 | −62% | 552 | 1863 | 238% | Sub18 | 9705 | 1959 | −80% | 0 | 5181 | Inf | ||
Sub19 | 1556 | 2972 | 91% | 6238 | 4362 | −30% | Sub19 | 2072 | 4972 | 140% | 7039 | 2554 | −64% | ||
Sub20 | 6001 | 2295 | −62% | 684 | 1831 | 168% | Sub20 | 116 | 849 | 632% | 227 | 308 | 36% | ||
Sub21 | 360 | 1157 | 221% | 2715 | 580 | −79% | Sub21 | 1975 | 1787 | −10% | 530 | 797 | 50% | ||
Sub22 | 570 | 480 | −16% | 1 | 6 | 500% | Sub22 | 8714 | 4877 | −44% | 1112 | 3986 | 258% | ||
Mean | 3097 | 2085 | −33% | 1594 | 1991 | 25% | Sub23 | 1039 | 1478 | 42% | 1052 | 1183 | 12% | ||
Mean | 3529 | 2380 | −33% | 1190 | 2181 | 83% | |||||||||
| |||||||||||||||
P < 0.00001 | 850 | 1350 | 59% | 59 | 245 | 315% | P < 0.00001 | 2231 | 902 | −60% | 87 | 1486 | 1608% | ||
Group | P < 0.001 | 5831 | 4680 | −20% | 821 | 4722 | 475% | Group | P < 0.001 | 8505 | 3509 | −59% | 2252 | 7520 | 234% |
P < 0.01 | 21067 | 7953 | −34% | 3521 | 11687 | 232% | P < 0.01 | 14955 | 6401 | −57% | 6098 | 14016 | 130% |
The activations and deactivations are thresholded at P < 0.00001, uncorrected. ∆>100% are shown in bold and colored in red (activations) or light blue (deactivations). ∆<−50% are shown in bold and colored in orange (activations) or green (deactivations). Abbreviations: ∆: (PSGS − NO PSGS)/NO PSGS∗100%.