Table 3.
Reference | Study Design/Population | TMZ Pretreatment | TMZ Regimen | n | Radiographic Response (%) | PFS6* (%) | mPFS* (mo) | mOS* (mo) | WHO Grades 3/4 Toxicities (n) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Temozolomide-Naive Population | |||||||||
Brada et al.24 | Phase II, open-label, uncontrolled TMZ at 1st relapse. Median age: 54 y; median time to 1st relapse: 8.1 mo |
No (40% of pts had prior nitrosourea-containing chemo-therapy) | Chemotherapy-naive pts: 200 mg/m2/d p.o. for 1st 5 d of 28-d cycle. Pts with previous nitrosourea-containing adjuvant chemotherapy: 150 mg/m2/d for 1st 5 d of 28-d cycle |
126 |
CR: 2 PR: 8 SD: 57 |
18 | 2.1 | 5.4 |
Hematologic: 30 Nonhematologic: 30 |
Brandes et al.39 | Phase II, 2nd relapse |
No (previous PCV) | 150 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d | 22 |
CR: 2 PR: 3 SD: 4 |
31.8 | 7.6 |
Hematologic: 4 Nonhematologic: 2 |
|
Brandes et al.40 | Phase II. Mean age: 48.4 y; median KPS: 80. 2nd relapse |
No (previous PCV) | 150 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d | 42 |
CR: 2 PR: 6 SD: 9 PD: NA |
24 | NA | 7.0 |
Hematologic: 1 Nonhematologic: 0 |
Khan et al.41 | Phase II, prospective, extended, low-dose, single-center | No | 75 mg/m2/d for 42 d q70d | 28 |
CR: 0 PR: 0 SD: 11 PD: 17 |
19 | 2.3 | 7.7 |
Hematologic: 8 Nonhematologic: 0 |
Wick et al.46 | Phase II, nonrandomized, prospective | No | 150 mg/m2 on days 1–7 and days 15–21 of 28-d cycles for max 12 cycles | 21 |
CR: 0 PR: 2 SD: 17 PD: 2 |
48 | 4.9 | NA |
Hematologic: 10 Nonhematologic: 7 |
Chan et al.42 | Prospective, open-label, compassionate use in Chinese pts | No | 200 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d for 4 cycles | 13 | NA | 21.0 | NA | NA |
Hematologic: 0 Nonhematologic: 0 |
Brandes et al.43 | Phase II. Median age: 57 y; Median KPS: 90 |
No | 75 mg/m2/d for 21 d q28d | 33 |
CR: 1 PR: 2 SD: 17 |
30.3 | 3.8 | 9.3 |
Hematologic: 14 Nonhematologic: 4 |
Nagane et al.44 | Prospective, open-label. Mean age: 48.2 y; Median KPS: 70 |
No (89.5% had previous nitrosourea-based therapy) | 150–200 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d | 19 |
CR: 1 PR: 3 SD: 6 PD: 7 |
22.2 | 2.2 | 9.9 |
Hematologic: 5 Nonhematologic: 9 |
Balmaceda et al.45 | Phase II, single-arm, multicenter. Median age: 43 y; 1st relapse: n = 48; ≥2 relapses: n = 20 |
No (previous non-nitrosourea: n = 7; nitrosourea: n = 33; none: n = 28) | 200 mg/m2 initial dose, then 9 consecutive doses at 90 mg/m2 q12h for 28 d; increased to 100 mg/m2 q12h in absence of toxicity | 68 |
CR: 3 PR: 18 SD: 22 PD: 19 |
35 | 4.0 | 9.0 | NA |
Temozolomide-Pretreated Population | |||||||||
Franceschi et al.48 | Retrospective analysis | Yes | 150–200 mg/m2/d for 5 d, q28d in 13 pts, 25 mg/m2/d continuously in 1 pt | 9 |
CR: 2 PR: 2 SD: 2 PD: 3 |
NA | 7.0 | 12+ |
Hematologic: 1 Nonhematologic: 0 |
Kong et al.49 | Pilot study, metronomic. Median age: 48.3 y | Yes | 40 mg/m2/d (3 mo) | 12 |
CR: 0 PR: 2 SD: 5 PD: 5 |
58.3 | 6.0 | 11 |
Hematologic: 0 Nonhematologic: 0 |
Wick et al.47 | Prospective, nonrandomized: alternating weekly regimen. Median age: 51 y |
9/64 pts had received TMZ (+ CCNU) | 150 mg/m2 on days 1–7 and days 15–21 q28d (1-wk on, 1-wk off) | 64 | NA | 43.8 | 5.5 | NA | NA |
Wick et al.54b | Retrospective analysis, 3 centers, 2000–2007. Median age: 52 y. 2 cohorts: TMZ escalation with progression during TMZ vs TMZ rechallenge after SD and disease-free interval |
Yes | 75 mg/m2/d (days 1–42 during radiotherapy), plus 150–200 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d or 150–200 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d or 150 mg/m2/d for 1-wk on, 1-wk off or 75 mg/m2/d for 21 d q28d or 40 mg/d continuousc |
47 | NA | 27.7 (progressive cohort 26.3 vs stable cohort 28.6%) | 5.8 (progressive cohort 6.6 vs stable cohort 5.3) | Hematologic: 22 Nonhematologic: 10 | |
Berrocal et al.50 | Phase II, multicenter | Yes | 85 mg/m2 for 21 d q28d | GB: 27 AA: 15 Misc: 5 |
CR: 0 PR: 2 SD: 15a PD: 30a |
0 | NA | 5.1a | NA |
Perry et al.51 | Phase II, continuous, dose-intense (RESCUE study), multicenter. Pts prospectively divided into 3 groups (early, extended, and rechallenge) per timing of progression during adjuvant therapy |
Yes | 50 mg/m2/d continuous for max 1 y or progression | 91 | NA | 23.9 (early 27.3; extended 7.4; rechallenge 35.7) | NA (early 3.6; extended 1.8; rechallenge 3.7) | 9.3 | NA |
Kong et al.52 | Phase II, low-dose, continuous (metronomic). Median age: 51 y |
Yes | 40–50 mg/m2/d | 38 |
CR: 0 PR: 2 SD: 21 |
32.5 | 4.0 | 9.6 |
Hematologic: 4 Nonhematologic: 0 |
Hammond et al.53 (prelim results only) | Phase II, dose-intense, single-arm, 1st recurrence. Median age: 57 y; median KPS: 90 |
Yes | 75–100 mg/m2/d for 21 d q28d | 47 |
CR: 0 PR: 6 SD: 18 |
23 | 2.3 | 13 |
Hematologic: 7 Nonhematologic: NA |
Randomized Studies | |||||||||
Yung et al.23 | Phase II, randomized, multicenter, open-label. Median age: 51–52 y; 1st relapse: 100% |
No (65%–68% of pts received prior nitrosourea) | TMZ 150–200 mg/m2/d for 5 d q28d or procarbazine 150 mg/m2/d (or 125 mg/m2/d if prior chemotherapy) p.o. for 28 d, repeated q56d |
112 113 |
CR: 0 PR: 6 SD: 45 CR: 0 PR: 6 SD: 31 |
21 8 |
2.9 1.9 |
NA |
Hematologic: 14 Nonhematologic: 12 Hematologic: 9 Nonhematologic: 17 |
Brada et al.55 | Prospective, randomized 1st progression: 100% |
No (chemotherapy-naive) | TMZ 200 mg/m2 for 5 d or TMZ 100 mg/m2 for 21 d or PCV |
GB: 72 AA: 15 GB: 66 AA: 15 GB: 139 AA: 23 |
NA | NA | 5.0a 4.2a 3.6a |
8.5a 6.6a 6.7a |
Hematologic: 38a Nonhematologic: 37a Hematologic: 28a Nonhematologic: 38a Hematologic: 57a Nonhematologic: 64a |
Abbreviations: AA, anaplastic astrocytoma; CCNU, lomustine; CR, complete response; GB, glioblastoma; KPS, Karnofsky performance score; mOS, median overall survival; mPFS, median progression-free survival; PCV, procarbazine, CCNU, and vincristine; PD, progressive disease; PFS6, 6-month PFS rate; PR, partial response; pts, patients; SD, stable disease.
For the most part, only GB data are presented in the table. We have reported enrollment numbers for different patient populations only when all data in a paper are presented for combined patient populations.
*Disease PFS and OS were calculated from beginning of retreatment with TMZ.
aData are presented for GB patients only except for the Berrocal study,50 where 27 patients had GB, 15 had AA, and 5 had miscellaneous brain tumors, and the Brada study,55 where 277 patients had GB, 53 had AA, and 20 had miscellaneous brain tumors.
bRetrospective study.
c11 patients also received 13-cis-retinoic acid or pegylated liposomal doxorubicin.