Skip to main content
. 2012;123:79–90.

TABLE 2.

Lyme Disease: Comparison of Evidence-based Guidelines Versus Non-evidence-based Concepts Favored by LLMDs and Advocacy Groups

Description Evidence-based Not Evidence-based
Terminology Late Lyme disease Chronic Lyme disease
Post-Lyme disease syndrome Chronic Lyme disease
Epidemiology Tick-borne Sexually transmitted
Known geography Geographically unrestricted
Congenital infection
Pathophysiology Not an intracellular pathogen; no evidence of cystic forms in vivo Chronic infection resistant to antibiotics due to cyst formation or intracellular location
Stealth mechanisms establish and maintain chronic infection
Clinical Objective and subjective signs and symptoms Subjective symptoms only necessary for diagnosis
Treatment effective for early or late infection If not treated early, infection may be incurable
Defined clinical spectrum Cause of learning disabilities, autism, multiple sclerosis, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, Parkinson's disease, Morgellons disease, psychiatric disease (Lyme rage), Alzheimer's disease,
Occasional tick-borne disease co-infections Frequent co-infections (Babesia, Bartonella, Ehrlichia, Anaplasma, Chlamydophila, Mycoplasma)
Rare reports of death related to Lyme disease Lethal disease
Diagnostic tests Negative Lyme serology seen in early infection Seronegative Lyme disease common, late disease
IgM immunoblot used for acute illness diagnosis only IgM immunoblot sufficient to diagnose long-standing symptoms
FDA approved B. burgdorferi serology Lyme specialty labs using non-validated tests or test interpretations
Use of markers CD57, C4a
Therapy Single antibiotic course 10-28 days with rare situations to retreat Persistent symptoms demand long-term treatment until resolution of symptoms (months-years)
Treated patients with persistent symptoms have no evidence of remaining infection Combination and/or parenteral antibiotics necessary for cure

†Data derived from (2, 3, 36, 37).

‡Data derived from (12, 38, 39).