Skip to main content
. 2013 Jan 9;8(1):e53184. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0053184

Table 2. Meta-analysis of observational data on antibiotic (AB) susceptibility (in %) in children with severe acute malnutrition (SAM) or not only SAM (Mixed-NUT).

Author Country N Age Bacterial antibiotic susceptibility (%)a
Mths AMX CTX GEN AGE CHL CIP CRO COA
SAM only
Babirekere [33] Uganda 134 6–24 23.3 6.7 33.3 - 60 97 100 -
Bachou (HIV+) [34] Uganda 30 12–24 53 21 78 - 55 93 84 56
Bachou (HIV−) [34] Uganda 39 12–24 31 23 81 - 36 93 90 51
Berkley (SAM subgroup) [35] Kenya 1182 7–35 57 42 - 87 77 - 94 -
Caksen [36] Turkey 31 1–30 - 17 100 - - 82 82 -
Mirabeau [37] Nigeria 203 <60 - - 85 - - - 61 -
Noorani [38] Kenya 91 <60 - - 80 - - 80 80 -
Rabasa [39] Nigeria 194 3–60 - 22.7 77 - - - - 22.7
Reed [40] S. Africa 863 <60 - - - 95.8 - - - -
Median 42 22 80 91.4 57.5 93 84 51
IQR 27–55 17–23 77–85 87–96 46–69 82–93 80–94 23–56
Population Weighted * mean (Meta-analysis): 52.9 35.4 72.8 90.7 73.7 90.0 89.3 30.7
Mixed-NUT. f
Bahwere [41] Congo 779 1–16 14.3 79.3 100 - 20.7 - 100 -
Bejon(<14 d) [42] Kenyad 690 <14 d 28 71 91 76b 81 99 95c -
Bejon (>14 d) [42] Kenyae 690 >14 d 28 39 73 76b 62 99 - -
Berkley (All) [35] Kenya 11847 7–35 59 54 - 88 81 - 93 -
Wolff (UTI) [43] Multiple <60 12 32 87 - 27 80 67 83
Median 28 54 89 76 62 99 94 83
IQR 14–28 39–71 80–96 76–88 27–81 80–99 80–97 -
Population Weighted * mean (Meta-analysis): 53.5 55.5 88.5 86.7 76.7 99.0 93.5 83.0

IQR: 25–75 inter-quartile range.

*

Mean susceptibility weighed proportionally (coefficient) to number of patients (N) per study;

a

 = Cumulated susceptibilities of all isolated bacteria. Abbreviations: AMX = amoxicillin (or ampicillin), CTX = co-trimoxazol, GEN = Gentamicin, AGE = AMX-GEN combination, CHL = chloramphenicol (b 91% susceptible to CHL-GEN); CIP = Ciprofloxacin, CRO = Ceftriaxone (c: in this case Cefotaxime instead, similar spectrum); COA = AMX-Clavulanate combination.

d

: age: <14 days of life,

e

: age>14 days of life.