Table 1. List of studies exploring effects of cushion species on other plants.
Study | Year | Species | Altitude (m a.s.l.) | region | temperature regime | rainfall | effect |
Pyšek a Liška | 1991 | Sibbaldia tetrandra | 3800 | Pamiro-Alai, 42°N | - | 714 | + |
Nuňez et al. | 1999 | Mulinum leptacanthum, Oreopolus glacialis | 1550–1600 | Andes, 41°S | A 3°C | 1000 | + |
Badano et al. | 2002 | Oreopolus glacialis | 1900 | Andes, 37°S | 2300 | + but species specific | |
Cavieres et al. | 2002 | Bolax gummifera | 700–900 | Andes, 50°S | A 5°C | 900–1000 | + and more evident in higher altitudes |
Arroyo et al. | 2003 | Azorella monantha | 700–900 | Andes, 50°S | A 5°C | 900–1000 | + and great altitudinal variation |
Cavieres et al. | 2005 | Azorella monantha | 3100–3300 | Andes, 33°S | 3.0°C April, 7.6°C February | 943 | + |
Acuňa-Rodriguez et al. | 2006 | Laretia acaulis | 2800 | Andes, 33°S | A 5.4°C, S 10°C | 400–900 | + |
Badano et al. | 2006 | Azorella monantha | 3580–3630 | Andes, 33°S | S 4°C, 4–5 months | >900 | cushion added new species into the community |
Badano & Cavieres | 2006a | Azorella monantha, Azorella madreporica, Adesmia subterranea | 3200–4000 | Andes, 30–33°S | A 4.6°C (3700 m) | 242–900 | + |
Badano & Cavieres | 2006b | Pycnophyllum bryoides, Azorella madreporica, Adesmia subterranea, Azorella monantha, Laretia acaulis, Mulinum leptacanthum, Oreopolus glacialis, Discaria nana | 1600–4400 | Andes, 23–41°S | – | + | |
Cavieres et al. | 2006 | Laretia acaulis | 2800–3200 | Andes, 33°S | S 7–12°C (2600 m), 3–7.6°C (3150 m) | 445–943 | increased facilitation at lower (drier) site |
Zoller & Lenzin | 2006 | Eritrichium nanum | 2170–3320 | Alps | – | 2170–3320 | + |
Cavieres et al. | 2007 | Laretia acaulis, Azorella monantha | 2800–3600 | Andes, 33°S | S 10°C (2800 m), ca. 4°C (3600 m) | 400–900 | + |
Badano & Marquet | 2008 | Azorella monantha | 3580–3630 | Andes, 33°S | S 4°C (3600 m) | >900 | + |
Fajardo et al. | 2008 | Azorella madreporica | 3580–3630 | Andes, 33°S | S 3–7.6 °C | 943 | +/− |
Antonsson et al. | 2009 | Silene acaulis | 1150–1447 | Scandes, 68°N | A –2.0 °C, warmest month mean 8.6 °C | 839 | + above a certain altitudinal threshold |
Arredondo-Núňez et al. | 2009 | a meta-analysis | 700–4400 | – | – | + | |
Badano & Marquet | 2009 | Azorella madreporica | 3400 | Andes, 33°S | S 6°C, 4–5 months | >900 | + |
Cavieres & Badano | 2009 | Mulinum leptacanthum, Discaria nana, Bolax gummifera, Azorella monantha, Pycnophyllum bryoides, Azorella madreporica, Adesmia subterranea, Laretia acaulis, Oreopolus glacialis | 900–4400 | Andes, 23–50°S | S 2.6–10.1°C | 42–1117 | always+but lower effects at both extremes of the environmental severity gradient. |
Haussmann et al. | 2009 | Azorella selago | 300 | Marion Island, 46°S | A 6°C | 2000 | |
Quiroz et al. | 2009 | Azorella madreporica | 3200–3580 | Andes, 33°S | W 1.7°C, S 6.8°C (3,150 m) | 400 | + and changes with altitude |
Sklenář | 2009 | Azorella dicranoides, Azorella corymbosa, Eudema nubigena, Hypochaeris sp., Xenophyllum humile | 4650 | Andes, 0°S | – | no data | + |
Badano et al. | 2010 | Azorella madreporica, Laretia acaulis, | 2700–3600 | Andes, 33°S | S 7–12°C (2600 m) | 400–900 | +/− depends on the environmental context |
Haussmann et al. | 2010 | Azorella selago | 300 | Marion Island, 46°S | A 6°C | 2000 | + |
Yang et al. | 2010 | Arenaria polytrichoides | 4500–4700 | Himalaya, 28°N | A –1.0°C, S 5.6°C | 680–790 | + and increases with altitude |
de Bello et al. | 2011 | Thylacospermum caespitosum | 5900 | Transhimalaya, 33°N | A –10.7°C, S 4.2°C, | 100 | - |
Anthelme et al. | 2012 | Azorella aretioides | 4400, 4550, 4700 | Andes, 0°S | 1.15°C, | 1000 | - lower elevation,+upper elevation |
this study | Thylacospermum caespitosum | 4850–5850 | Transhimalaya, 33°N | A –10.4 to –1.6°C, S 4.4 to 7.7°C | 100 | – |
For each study, the table indicates the cushion species that was studied, the elevational range considered (in m a.s.l.), the study region, the approximate mean yearly rainfall (mm year−1), mean annual (A), summer (S), winter (W) temperatures, and the effect detected (‘+’ indicates facilitation, ‘–’ indicates negative effects). Based on de Bello et al. [22].