Skip to main content
. 2012 Oct 19;27(1):28–36. doi: 10.1038/eye.2012.213

Table 1. Inclusion and exclusion criteria.

Inclusion criteria
 Studies of children aged 0 to <11 years
 AHT—ranking of abuse of 1–2
 nAHT—non-abusive aetiology confirmed (abuse excluded/accident confirmed)
 Ophthalmic examination performed by an ophthalmologist
 Ophthalmic findings described with reference to severity, location, and laterality
 
Exclusion criteria
 Consensus statements or personal practice studies
 Study exclusively addresses retinal findings in association with:
  Prior ophthalmic surgery
  Solid mass lesions of the eye (eg, retinoblastoma) or brain
  Post mortem examination alone (ie, where eyes not examined in life)
  Medical causes of RH
  RH found in the immediate postnatal period
  Blunt trauma to the eye
 AHT—ranking of abuse within study of 3–5 or mixed ranking where cases ranked 1–2 could not be extracted
 Ophthalmic examination performed by non-ophthalmologist
   
Ranking Criteria used to define abuse
1 Abuse confirmed at case conference or admitted by perpetrator, or independently witnessed (with or without subsequent legal proceedings)
2 Abuse confirmed by stated criteria including multidisciplinary assessment (social services/law enforcement/medical)
3 Abuse defined by stated criteria
4 Abuse stated but no supporting detail given
5 Suspected abuse