Table 1.
Study | Country | Methodology | Type of study | Technique | Phenomenon of interest | Participants | Analysis |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tolhurst [16] 2005 |
Australia |
Qualitative: phenomenology* |
Descriptive* |
Focus groups |
Factors influencing career interests of medical students. |
81 first and final year medical students. (36 male, 46 female). Three universities |
Interpretative. Thematic analysis. |
Saigal [17] 2007 |
Japan |
Qualitative: phenomenology* |
Descriptive* |
Semi-structured interviews (students), informal interviews (academic faculty). Field notes. |
Factors influencing medical specialty preference in Japan. Understanding of family medicine, primary care and subspecialty practice. |
25 medical students or 3rd to 6th year. (17 male, 8 female). One university |
Interpretative. Thematic analysis.* |
Scott [18] 2007 |
Canada |
Qualitative: phenomenology. |
Descriptive |
Focus groups Individual interviews |
Factors influencing medical students regarding a career in family medicine. |
33 medical students: end of preclinical years and end of the clinical years. (6 male, 27 female). Three universities |
Interpretative. Thematic analysis. |
Thistlethwaite [19] 2008 |
Australia |
Qualitative: phenomenology |
Exploratory-interpretative |
Semi-structured phone interviews |
Factors that influence students and junior doctors to choose or reject a career in general practice. |
13 medical students (3 male, 10 female), 5 junior doctors, 5 general practice registrars, 15 general physicians. One university. |
Interpretative. Thematic analysis. |
López-Roig [20] 2010 |
Spain |
Qualitative: case based research. Phenomenology |
Interpretative |
Focus groups Documental analysis |
Explore the reputation of and professional identification processes with family medicine practice among students. |
48 students: 27 2nd year medical students, 21 6th year medical students. One university |
Interpretative. Discursive thematic analysis.* |
Hogg [21] 2008 |
United Kingdom |
Mixed: qualitative interactionist and quantitative. |
Exploratory, descriptive and interpretative |
Focus groups Questionnaires |
Factors influencing medical students regarding a career in general practice. |
30 final year medical students after a general practice module: 15 took part in the focus groups. |
Interpretative. Framework analysis. |
Edgcumbe [22] 2008 |
United Kingdom |
Qualitative: framework system |
Exploratory |
Semi-structured interviews. Nominal groups |
Views about general practice as a potential career and factors shaping them. |
27 final year medical students (7 male, 8 female). 15 interviewed and 12 formed the nominal group. |
Interpretative. Framework system. |
Chirk-Jenn 2005 [23] |
Malaysia |
Qualitative: interpretative description. |
Exploratory |
Focus groups |
Perceptions of medical students towards primary care and factors that influence them. |
33 final year medical students (21 male, 12 female). Two universities. |
Thematic analysis. |
Firth 2007 [24] |
United Kingdom |
Qualitative: phenomenology |
Exploratory |
Semi-structured interviews |
Views of undergraduate students on their experiences of learning in primary care in a curriculum with a strong community base. |
11 medical students from 3rd to 5th course (6 male, 5 female) |
Interpretative. Thematic analysis. Grounded Theory. |
Mutha 1997 [25] | USA | Qualitative: phenomenology | Descriptive | Focus groups, two individual interviews, surveys. | To identify beliefs and values that influence career decisions of medical students. | 52 medical students from 4th to 5th course (25 male, 27 female). Three medical schools. | Content and thematic analysis. |
*Unclear, not explicitly reported.