Skip to main content
. 2013 Feb;51(2):540–546. doi: 10.1128/JCM.02620-12

Table 1.

Results for standardsa

Standard Nominal log10 concnb Real-time PCR
Digital PCR
Variability (P value)
No. of positive specimens/total no. of attempts Mean viral load (log10 no. of copies/ml) SD % CV No. of positive specimens/total no. of attempts Mean viral load (log10 no. of copies/ml) SD % CV
AcroMetrix 2.48 9/9 2.11 0.34 16.11 7/7c 2.23 0.24 10.76 0.409
AcroMetrix 3.48 9/9 3.15 0.12 3.81 8/8c 3.06 0.08 2.61 0.248
AcroMetrix 4.48 9/9 4.19 0.12 2.86 8/8c 4.16 0.03 0.72 0.003
AcroMetrix 5.48 9/9 5.25 0.07 1.33 9/9 5.19 0.03 0.58 0.048
NIST 1 0/9 0 0 NA 1/9 0.27 0.82 303.7 NA
NIST 2 7/9 1.09 0.67 61.47 3/9 0.83 1.24 149.4 0.104
NIST 3 9/9 2.35 0.23 9.79 7/9 2.1 1.2 57.14 <0.001
NIST 4 9/9 3.29 0.09 2.74 9/9 3.66 0.1 2.73 0.637
NIST 5 9/9 4.34 0.05 1.15 9/9 4.63 0.07 1.51 0.348
NIST 6 9/9 5.35 0.06 1.12 9/9 5.6 0.05 0.89 0.394
NIST 6.7 9/9 6.1 0.11 1.8 9/9 6.21 0.08 1.29 0.345
WHO 1 6/9 1.17 0.91 77.78 1/7c 0.29 0.76 262.07 0.660
WHO 2 9/9 2.18 0.38 17.43 3/7c 0.91 1.14 125.27 0.008
WHO 3 9/9 3.16 0.11 3.48 9/9 2.71 0.1 3.69 0.727
WHO 4 9/9 4.14 0.11 2.66 8/8c 3.77 0.04 1.06 0.007
WHO 5 9/9 5.13 0.07 1.36 9/9 4.75 0.02 0.42 0.004
WHO 6 9/9 5.99 0.05 0.83 8/8c 5.72 0.02 0.35 0.020
a

The number of positive specimens/number of attempts, the mean log-transformed measurements, and standard deviation of the log-transformed measurements are given for each technology at each concentration of each standard. Bartlett's test was used to compare the variability of the two technologies, based on the SD. A small-variability P value indicates that there is significant evidence that the two technologies do not have equal standard deviation in their measurements. CV, coefficient of variation; NA, not available.

b

Nominal concentrations in IU/ml for AcroMetrix and WHO standards and number of copies/ml for NIST standards.

c

Decreased replicates due to failure of the instrument (either failed to generate or read the droplet).