Table 2.
Dimension | Completeness | Correctness | Concordance | Plausibility | Currency | Total |
Method | ||||||
Gold standard | 12–35 | 12–23 25 26 28–48 | 37 | |||
Data element agreement | 49–55 56 | 49 50 52–54 56–67 | 51 59 68–72 | 38 73 | 26 | |
Element presence | 36–39 49 57–59 68 69 74–86 | 23 | ||||
Data source agreement | 79 87–89 | 90 | 91–96 | 11 | ||
Distribution comparison | 97–100 | 31 57 97 | 50 101 102 103 | 10 | ||
Validity checks | 32 62 104 105 106 | 73 89 | 7 | |||
Log review | 73 | 36 46 52 84 | 5 | |||
Total | 61 | 57 | 16 | 7 | 4 |
In decreasing order of frequency, the dimensions are listed from left to right, and the methods from top to bottom. The numbers in the cells correspond to the article references featuring each dimension–method pair.