Table 1. Interventions meeting selection criteria for analysis of prevention of preterm birth.
Interventions | Evidence of efficacy for preterm birth by GRADE criteria |
Rec. for implementation for preterm birth |
Rationale for inclusion / exclusion in analysis |
---|---|---|---|
Smoking cessation | High | Strong |
Included: GRADE recommendation according to GAPPS |
Progesterone | High | Strong |
Included : GRADE recommendation according to GAPPS |
Cerclage | High no effect | Strong against |
Included: newer evidence16 shows efficacy in women with prior preterm birth and short cervix. Potential for implementation expected to be high among HIC, unlike that for L- and MIC, which was focus of GAPPS |
Decrease non-medically indicated Caesarean delivery and induction |
n/a | n/a |
Included: relevant in HIC. (Not included in15 GAPPS given focus on L- and MIC) |
Limit multiple embryo transfer in assisted reproductive technology |
n/a | n/a |
Included: relevant in HIC. (Not included in15 given focus on L- and MIC) |
Zinc supplementation | High | Weak |
Excluded: weak GRADE recommendation according to GAPPS |
Notes: GAPPS Global Alliance for Prevention of Prematurity and Stillbirth, report.15 New evidence supporting efficacy of cerclage from Berghella et al Obstetrics and Gynecology 2011.16
GRADE = Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation.
H-, M-, LIC are high-, middle-, and low-income countries. See webappendix p.18-19 for effect estimate applied for each intervention and webappendix p. 17 for other intervention that were considered but excluded from analysis.