Table 1. Results of the statistical tests.
stimulus 1 | N | stimulus 2 | N | focal female | behavior | Mann-Whitney U | U | Z |
Intraspecific test (I. alpestris+I. alpestris) | ||||||||
Ia | 20 | MW | 20 | I. alpestris | f | <0.001* | 42.000 | −4.621 |
tt | <0.05* | 123.000 | −2.207 | |||||
w | <0.01* | 126.500 | −2.719 | |||||
Ia | 20 | W | 20 | I. alpestris | f | <0.001* | 30.000 | −5.109 |
tt | <0.001* | 93.000 | −3.269 | |||||
w | <0.05* | 120.000 | −3.097 | |||||
MW | 20 | W | 20 | I. alpestris | f | 0.152 | 180.000 | −1.432 |
tt | 0.130 | 156.000 | −1.514 | |||||
w | 0.317 | 190.000 | −1.000 | |||||
Interspecific test (I. alpestris+L. helveticus) | ||||||||
Ia | 15 | W | 15 | I. alpestris | f | <0.001* | 90.000 | −3.782 |
tt | <0.001* | 22.500 | −4.215 | |||||
w | <0.05* | 75.000 | −2.396 | |||||
Lh | 15 | W | 15 | I. alpestris | f | 1.000 | 112.500 | 0.000 |
tt | 0.150 | 97.500 | −1.438 | |||||
w | 1.000 | 112.500 | 0.000 | |||||
Interspecific test (I. alpestris+L. helveticus) | ||||||||
Ia | 15 | W | 15 | L. helveticus | f | 1.000 | 112.500 | 0.000 |
tt | 0.524 | 104.500 | −0.637 | |||||
w | 1.000 | 112.500 | 0.000 | |||||
Lh | 15 | W | 15 | L. helveticus | f | <0.001* | 37.500 | −3.707 |
tt | <0.05* | 69.000 | −2.225 | |||||
w | 0.317 | 105.000 | −1.000 | |||||
Intraspecific vs. interspecific female preference | ||||||||
Ia (+I. alpestris) | 20 | Ia (+L. helveticus) | 15 | I. alpestris | f | 0.340 | 121.500 | −0.954 |
tt | 0.183 | 110.500 | −1.333 | |||||
w | 0.398 | 128.000 | −0.846 |
Ia = alpine newt male courtship water, MW = water in which non-courting alpine newt males had been kept, W = control water, Lh = palmate newt male courtship water, N = number of different females used in the experimental design. P-values smaller than 0.05 are considered significant and are indicated with an asterisk. The values for Kruskal-Wallis tests were as follows: intraspecific tests (Pf<0.05, Ptt<0.05 and Pw<0.05), interspecific tests for alpine newt females (Pf<0.05, Ptt<0.05 and Pw<0.05), interspecific tests for palmate newt females (Pf<0.05, Ptt<0.05 and Pw = 0.096).