Skip to main content
. 2013 Feb 22;8(2):e57832. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0057832

Table 1. Likelihood ratio tests on mixed model logistic regression on plastic traits.

Model Effect tested AIC X2 p
a) Hatching time
t+s+d+sxd 15213
s+d+sxd t 15750 539.2 <0.001
t*p+s+d+sxd t x p 15214 2.8 0.24
t+t|s+d+sxd t x s 15203 14.1 <0.001
t+s+t|d+sxd t x d 15182 35.3 <0.001
t+s+d+t|sxd t x s x d 15188 29.0 <0.001
b) Hatchling length
t+s+d+sxd −3154.1
s+d+sxd t −2962.8 193.3 <0.001
t*p+s+d+sxd t x p −3150.2 0.2 0.90
t+t|s+d+sxd t x s −3150.1 0.1 0.96
t+s+t|d +sxd t x d −3168.5 18.4 <0.001
t+s+d+t|sxd t x s x d −3150.1 0 1
c) Yolk sac volume
t+s+d+sxd 9669.2
s+d+sxd t 9677.7 10.5 0.001
t*p+s+d+sxd t x p 9669.3 3.9 0.14
t+t|s+d+sxd t x s 9672.2 1.0 0.62
t+s+t|d+sxd t x d 9672.7 0.5 0.78
t+s+d+t|sxd t x s x d 9673.2 0 1

Reference models are indicated in bold. To test the effect of treatment, the reference model was compared to a model lacking treatment. For the other effects, the reference model was compared to a model incorporating the effect of interest. t: treatment; p: population cross type (within vs. between); s: sire; d: dam