Table 1. Association Study Cohort Sizes in Essential Tremor (ET) Genetics Research.
Study | ET n | Control n | ET Cohort Source | Overall Result |
ETM1 | ||||
HS1-BP3 828C→G variant | 49 | 92 | United States | Negative |
Shatunov et al, 200563 | ||||
HS1-BP3 828C→G variant | 73 | 304 | United States | Positive |
Higgins et al, 200661 | Note initial 2005 report from same group with G variant in ET cases in 2 of 21 US ET families, not ET or unaffecteds in the other families, and not 150 US controls or 73 ET Singaporean cases | |||
HS1-BP3 828C→G variant | 222 | 132 | United States | Negative |
Deng et al, 200562 | ||||
ETM2 | ||||
ETM2 sequence variants | 30 | 30 | Korean | Positive |
Kim et al, 200537 | ||||
ETM2 polymorphisms | 61 | 68 | Czech | Negative |
Zahorakova et al, 201038 | ||||
DRD3 312A→G variant | 104 | 116 | Latvian | Negative |
Inashkina et al, 200839 | ||||
DRD3 312A→G variant | 116 | 158 | Italian | Negative |
Vitale et al, 200870 | ||||
DRD3 312A→G variant | 163 | 192 | Singaporean | Negative |
Tan et al, 200768 | ||||
DRD3 312A→G variant | 201 | 282 | Spanish | Positive |
Garcia-Martin et al, 200966 | ||||
DRD3 312A→G variant | 276 | 184 | United States | Positive |
Jeanneteau et al, 200665 | 30 | 50 | French | |
DRD3 312A→G variant | 299 | 528 | German, Danish, French | Negative |
Lorenz et al, 200969 | ||||
DRD3 312A→G variant | 433 | 272 | United States | Negative |
Blair et al, 200867 | ||||
LINGO genes | ||||
LINGO1 rs9652490 and rs11856808 | 109 | 430 | Chinese Han | Negative |
Zuo et al, 201054 | ||||
LINGO1 rs9652490 | 117 | 160 | Chinese | Negative |
Wu et al, 201157 | Note combining with Tan et al53 plus unpublished data into 307 ET and 804 control, meta-analysis positive | |||
LINGO1 rs9652490 | 141 | 130 | Latvian | Positive |
Radovica et al, 201252 | 9 other SNPs including rs11856808 negative | |||
LINGO4 variants | 150 | 300 | Chinese Han | Negative |
Liang et al, 201259 | ||||
LINGO1 rs9652490 | 190 | 733 | Singaporean | Positive |
Tan et al, 200953 | ||||
LINGO1 rs9652490 and rs11856808 | 226 | 1117 | Spanish | Negative |
Lorenzo-Betancor et al, 201155 | ||||
LINGO1 SNPs | 257 | 265 | United States | Positive for rs9652490 and others |
Clark et al, 201051 | Negative for rs11856808 and others out of 15 SNPs total | |||
Note meta-analysis combining 3 or 4 published cohorts46, 50, 51, 53 also positive | ||||
LINGO1 rs9652490 and rs11856808 | 259 | 479 | French Canadian | Negative |
Bourassa et al, 201156 | ||||
LINGO2 variants | 327 | 499 | Chinese, Singaporean | Positive for rs7033345 and rs10812774 of 8 variants |
Wu et al, 201158 | ||||
LINGO1 SNPs | 332 | 574 | German, French | Positive for rs9652490 and 1 other |
Thier et al, 201048 | Negative for rs11856808 and others out of 10 SNPs total | |||
LINGO1 rs9652490 | 356 | 428 | North American | Positive |
Vilarino-Guell et al, 201050 | ||||
GWAS | 452 | 14,394 | Icelandic | Positive for LINGO1 rs9652490 and rs11856808 in initial cohort; rs9652490 only in confirmatory cohorts |
Stefansson et al, 200946 | 281 | 1188 | Austrian, German, United States | |
LINGO1 and LINGO2 variants | 1247 | 642 | North American | Positive for LINGO1 rs9652490 and 4 others of 16 total, and LINGO2 rs1412229 alone of 21. |
Vilarino-Guell et al, 201049 | ||||
SNCA | ||||
REP1 length | 46 | 100 | United States | Positive |
Tan et al, 200075 | ||||
SNCA variants | 106 | 90 | Italian | Negative |
Pigullo et al, 200390 | ||||
SNCA variants | 647 | 1285 | North American | Negative |
Ross et al, 201191 | ||||
Other variants | ||||
GABAAR subunit genes variants | 200 | 250 | Spanish | Negative |
Garcia-Martin et al, 201194, 95 | ||||
GABAAR subunits and GABA transporter genes variants | 503 | 818 | German, Dutch | Negative |
Thier et al, 201193 | ||||
HNMT rs11558538 | 204 | 295 | Spanish | Positive |
Ledesma et al, 200896 | ||||
HNMT rs11558538 | 338 | 409 | North American | Negative |
Keeling et al, 201097 |
Studies are grouped under genetic categories, and listed by first author and year of publication. Within hypothesis groups, studies are ordered by ET n. If the study combined cohorts in one analysis then the full ET n is used. If the same study used different cohorts in different analyses, the larger ET n is listed first. ET cohort source is geographical; some papers have further details on ethnicity. North American = United States and Canada. Overall result considers the main thrust of the study, with a few further notations; see text for comments on age of onset influences, and cited references for full study results details including specific genetic variants tested, haplotype analyses, methods.
Abbreviations: DRD3, dopamine D3 receptor gene; ET, essential tremor; ETM, Hereditary Essential Tremor, Online Mendelian Inheritance of Man (OMIM) locus designation; GABA, gamma-aminobutyric acid; GABAAR, gamma-aminobutyric acid A receptor; HNMT, histamine N-methyltransferase gene; HS1-BP3, HS1 binding protein 3 gene; LINGO, leucine-rich repeat- and Ig domain-containing Nogo receptor-interacting protein; numbered italicized LINGOs are genes encoding LINGO proteins; REP1, mixed dinucleotide repeat sequence in the SNCA promoter region; SNCA, gene encoding α-synuclein; SNPs, single nucleotide polymorphisms; US, United States.