Skip to main content
. 2013 Feb 14;2013:972471. doi: 10.1155/2013/972471

Table 1.

Grid used for assessing the papers (adapted from Moher).

Category Description Grading
A Sample size calculation, estimating the minimum number of participants required to detect a significant difference among compared groups 0 = did not exist/not mentioned/not clear
1 = was reported but not confirmed
2 = reported and confirmed

B Randomization and allocation concealment methods 0 = clearly inadequate
1 = possibly adequate
2 = clearly adequate

C Clear definition of inclusion and exclusion criteria 0 = no
1 = yes

D Completeness of follow-up (specified reasons for withdrawal and drop-outs for each group) 0 = no/not mentioned/not clear
1 = yes/no withdrawals or drop-outs occurred

E Experimental and control groups comparable at study baseline for important prognostic factors 0 = no
1 = unclear/possibly not comparable for one or more important prognostic factors
2 = clearly adequate

F Presence of masking 0 = no
1 = unclear/not complete
2 = yes

G Appropriate statistical analysis 0 = no
1 = unclear/possibly not the best method applied
2 = yes