Table 1.
Reference | Terminology used | Definition | Country | Setting | Health area | Team members |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Atwal and Caldwell24 | Multidisciplinary | Team members “having different professional backgrounds but who make complementary contributions to patient care” | UK | Acute care – hospital wards | Elder care Orthopedics Acute medicine | Doctor, nurse, occupational therapist, physiotherapist, and social worker |
Black11 | Interdisciplinary | Team members “[interact] to produce a final outcome on behalf of patients” | USA | Hospital – private, not-for-profit | Elder care | Medicine, nursing, and social work |
Chan et al27 | Multidisciplinary | “Team care coordinated by a leader who takes responsibility for overall patient care. Members contribute views and recommendations according to their particular expertise, which may be integrated by the leader” | Australia | General practice and community health care | Chronic disease | General practitioners and allied health providers including podiatrists, optometrists, diabetes educators, dietitians, cardiac rehabilitation workers, exercise physiologists, and psychologists |
Cioffi et al28 | Multidisciplinary | Use the definition provided by Schofield and Amodeo19: “a number of individuals from various disciplines [who] are involved in a project but work independently” | Australia | Community health care | Chronic disease | Community nurses, occupational therapist, physiotherapist, and social workers |
Delva et al31 | Interdisciplinary | “Groups of professionals who work collaboratively to develop processes and plans for patients” | Canada | University primary care teaching practice | Primary care | Teaching teams consisting of physicians, nurses, resident physicians, receptionist, secretaries, nutritionists, social workers, and administrative staff |
Gibbon et al25 | Interprofessional | “‘Processes’ of intervention” | UK | Hospital – stroke rehabilitation units | Stroke patients | Nurses, doctors, physiotherapists, occupational therapists, speech and language therapists, social workers, and clinical psychologist |
Multiprofessional | “The ‘structural’ components of a team” | UK | Hospital – stroke rehabilitation units | Stroke patients | Nurses, doctors, physiotherapists, occupational therapists, speech and language therapists, social workers, and clinical psychologist | |
Goldsmith et al29 | Interdisciplinary | “Collaboration among health care providers with specialized knowledge from multiple disciplines” | USA | Veterans Affairs hospital | Geriatric and palliative care | Social worker, chaplain, psychologist, nurse, and doctors |
Haggerty et al33 | Multidisciplinary | “Practitioners from various health disciplines collaborate in providing ongoing health care” | Canada | Community | Primary health care | Study based on Canadian primary health care experts: family physicians, nurses, academics, and decision makers |
Kim et al60 | Multidisciplinary | Specific to primary health care the authors define multidisciplinary as “PHC [primary health care] delivered by health professionals from multiple disciplines, including nurses, physicians, dentists, and public health doctors” | Korea | Nursing faculty and primary health care | Primary health care | Nurse, physician, social workers, and dentists |
Kuder et al30 | Interdisciplinary | “A team integrates its various disciplinary perspectives and maintains a network of cooperation and communication” | USA | Rural geriatric health care | Gerontology | Physician, nurse practitioner or physician assistant, pharmacist, and social worker |
Kvarnström26 | Interprofessional | “‘Inter’ relates to the dimension of collaboration […] ‘profession’ […] differentiates from the term ‘discipline’ in the sense that disciplines may be regarded as academic disciplines as well as sub-specialities within professions” | Sweden | Swedish local health care settings | Primary care, psychiatric care, geriatric care, rehabilitation | Occupational therapist, registered nurse, physiotherapist, medical social worker, administrative assistant, physician, practical nurse, psychologist, and speech therapist |
Mills et al35 | Interprofessional | “Teams work jointly to provide health care, where each member of the team contributes within the context of his or her profession” | Australia | Remote or isolated | Primary health care | Medical officers, specialist nurses, indigenous health workers, local indigenous health service managers, distant health service managers, and allied health professionals |
Molleman et al36 | Multidisciplinary | “Care providers with a range of occupational backgrounds collectively discussing a patient leading to collective decision-making and action” | Holland | N/A – survey distributed to medical specialists (nonspecific to setting) | Oncology and geriatrics | Geriatric team: head of geriatric department, clinical geriatrician, geriatrician internist, resident internal medicine specialist, psychiatrist, neurologist, social worker, specialized nurses, and psychologist Oncology team: intern oncologist, hematologist, specialized nurse, internal medicine resident, radiotherapist, social worker, dietitian, physiotherapist, mental care assistant, clinical chemist, pharmacist, and microbiologist |
Molleman et al44 | Multidisciplinary | Use the terminology in the context of medical teamwork: “work arrangement in which physicians from different medical specialities regularly meet to share, weigh and synthesize information concerning individual patients from a specific patient group, and where they, at least to some extent, collectively make decisions about diagnoses and treatment” | Holland | Hospital | Medical specialties | Physicians from different medical specialties |
Shaw32 | Interprofessional | Use the definition provided by D’Amour and Oandasan33: “The development of cohesive practice between professionals from different disciplines […] it involves continuous interaction and knowledge sharing between professionals […] all while seeking to optimize the patient’s participation” | Canada | Family health center in an urban teaching hospital | Primary care | Nurse, family physician, family medicine residents, dietitian, and pharmacist |
Solheim et al23 | Multidisciplinary | “Members maintain discipline-specific roles” | USA | Community | Primary health care | Nurse (nurse participants identified physicians and social workers as collaborators in team-based primary health care) |
Spencer and Cooper45 | Multidisciplinary | “Interdependency with other professionals and being able to combine perceptions and skills to synthesise a more complex and comprehensive plan of care” | UK | Hospital | Type 1 diabetes | General pediatric consultant, specialist nurse, specialist dietitian, and general psychologist |
Notes: Primary care draws from the biomedical model. It is a person’s first point of entry into the health system. Primary health care draws from the social model of health. It considers that people’s basic needs must first be met in order for health gain to occur.59
Abbreviation: N/A, not applicable.