Skip to main content
. 2013 Mar 7;8(3):e58082. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0058082

Table 3. Treatment outcomes of the included studies.

Study Postoperative Treatment Treatment (surgery/local ablation) (n) Follow-up (mo.) Recurrence rate (%) Survival rate (%)
1-year 2-year 3-year 1-year 2-year 3-year
Yoshiji et al. [9] VK2 (45 mg) 0/18 48.0 22.2 44 61.1 100 94.4 88.9
Control arm 0/25 48.0 24.0 48.0 68.0 100 92.0 88.0
Perindopril+VK2 (45 mg) 0/25 48.0 12.0 28.0 32.0 100 100 96.0
Perindopril 0/19 48.0 15.8 36.8 52.6 100 94.7 89.5
Mizuta et al. [10] VK2 (45 mg) 1/31 28.9 12.5 39.0 64.3 100 96.6 87.0
Control arm 3/26 27.7 55.2 83.2 91.6 96.4 80.9 64.0
Kakizaki et al. [11] VK2 (45 mg) 4/26 - 7.7 51.4 61.2 100 95.0 77.5
Control arm 7/23 - 28.3 64.1 90.1 95.8 90.2 66.4
Hotta et al. [12] VK2 (45 mg) 2/19 19.5 23.8 28.6 - 100 100 -
Control arm 2/22 16.5 33.3 46.5 73.3 87.5 81.7 81.7
Yoshida et al. [13] VK2 (45 mg) 9/173 36 31.2 - - 99.2 - -
VK2 (90 mg) 5/180 36 37.7 - - 98.7 - -
Control arm 7/174 36 28.2 - - 97.2 - -
Kubota et al. [15] VK2 (45 mg) 50/0 - 20.6 36.9 43.6 - - -
Control arm 51/0 - 30.0 52.0 76.1 - - -
Hosho et al. [16] VK2 (45 mg) 2/21 23.8 26.1 32.8 78.1 100 93.3 85.6
Control arm 7/42 26.9 49.0 61.7 67.6 93.3 79.1 56.5

Abbreviation: VK2, vitamin K2 analog.