Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Nov 15.
Published in final edited form as: Neuroimage. 2012 Jul 23;63(3):1633–1645. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.07.021

Table 2.

A
Summary of segmentation evaluation for select structures: brain rest, hippocampus (Hc), caudate putamen (CPu), substantia nigra (SN), anterior commissure (ac), corpus callosum (cc), lateral ventricles (LV). Data represent mean Dice coefficients±SEM. Minimum and maximum values are shown in bold characters.
Channel selection impacted the accuracy of segmentation.
C57BL/6 T1 (%) T2* (%) T1T2* (%) T1Tr (%) T1FA (%) T1RA (%) T2*FA (%) T2*RA (%) T2*Tr (%) T1RD (%) T2*RD (%) T1E0 (%) T2*E0(%) F(12,39) p
Brain rest 95.47±0.58 94.94±0.64 95.84±0.21 96.57±0.21 96.41±0.67 97.24±0.03 97.01±0.17 97.18±0.04 96.16±0.17 96.76±0.23 96.34±0.25 96.76±0.12 96.51±0.21 3.79 7.62E−04
Hc 84.37±0.71 84.14±2.62 83.43±2.40 87.29±1.51 88.67±1.62 90.64±0.50 90.53±0.77 90.75±0.71 87.85±1.19 89.62±1.67 88.69±1.46 89.29±0.83 89.75±0.91 3.13 0.0034
CPu 82.08±0.26 82.47±2.03 77.21±1.37 85.02±1.75 87.18±1.59 88.68±0.35 87.75±0.66 88.30±0.50 81.34±1.68 87.22±1.15 84.11±1.35 87.21±1.56 84.69±1.66 4.88 7.58E−05
SN 77.69±4.78 71.01±4.64 72.58±5.55 80.21±1.44 77.01±3.73 79.12±4.84 78.55±2.93 77.00±4.14 79.66±1.45 80.74±1.37 78.36±2.00 78.88±2.50 77.73±2.69 0.64 0.7945
ac 51.02±9.29 28.52±10.95 18.43±10.48 56.20±5.01 69.24±4.63 73.31±2.81 65.21±5.47 73.83±2.21 52.30±3.04 63.60±1.89 59.48±2.81 61.05±1.56 56.56±1.66 7.99 2.98E−07
cc 54.74±4.43 54.10±3.64 51.67±2.11 54.07±5.13 67.87±6.68 70.28±2.40 70.10±1.19 71.33±1.28 45.21±4.16 64.66±7.34 55.72±7.94 62.34±3.76 55.50±6.10 3.04 0.0042
LV 30.49±8.21 44.09±3.24 32.38±7.84 56.41±6.60 57.89±5.29 61.42±5.90 59.72±2.18 61.80±1.29 27.46±4.55 62.33±6.83 43.32±7.12 67.60±4.19 50.26±7.07 5.46 2.39E−05
B
Multichannel segmentation of C57BL/6mice incorporating DTI outperformed single channel segmentation using conventional contrast.
Factor 1 Factor 2 Diff (%) CI1 CI2 p
Hc
T2*RA T1T2* 7.32 0.11 14.53 0.04*
T1RA T1T2* 7.21 0.00 14.42 0.05
T2*FA T1T2* 7.10 −0.11 14.31 0.06
T2*RA T2* 6.61 −0.60 13.82 0.10
T2*RA T1 6.37 −0.84 13.58 0.13
CPu
T1RA T1T2* 11.48 3.82 19.13 0.0003*
T2*RA T1T2* 11.09 3.44 18.74 0.0006*
T2*FA T1T2* 10.55 2.89 18.20 0.0012*
T1RD T1T2* 10.01 2.36 17.66 0.003*
T1E0 T1T2* 10.00 2.35 17.65 0.003*
T1FA T1T2* 9.97 2.32 17.63 0.003*
T2*RD T1T2* 9.26 1.61 16.91 0.01*
T1Tr T1T2* 7.81 0.16 15.46 0.04*
T2*E0 T1T2* 7.48 −0.17 15.13 0.06
T1RA T2*Tr 7.35 −0.30 15.00 0.07
T2*RA T2*Tr 6.96 −0.69 14.61 0.11
LV
T1E0 T2*Tr 40.14 11.22 69.06 0.001*
T1E0 T1 37.11 8.19 66.03 0.003*
T1E0 T1T2* 35.22 6.30 64.14 0.006*
T1RD T2*Tr 34.87 5.95 63.79 0.007*
T2*RA T2*Tr 34.34 5.42 63.26 0.01*
T1RA T2*Tr 33.96 5.04 62.88 0.01*
T2*FA T2*Tr 32.26 3.34 61.18 0.02*
T1RD T1 31.84 2.92 60.76 0.02*
T2*RA T1 31.31 2.39 60.23 0.02*
T1RA T1 30.93 2.01 59.85 0.03*
T1FA T2*Tr 30.43 1.51 59.35 0.03*
T1RD T1T2* 29.96 1.03 58.88 0.04*
T2*RA T1T2* 29.42 0.50 58.34 0.04*
T2*FA T1 29.23 0.31 58.15 0.046*
T1RA T1T2* 29.04 0.12 57.96 0.048*
T1Tr T2*Tr 28.95 0.03 57.87 0.05
T1FA T1 27.40 −1.52 56.32 0.08
T2*FA T1T2* 27.34 −1.58 56.26 0.08
ac
T2*RA T1T2* 55.40 26.70 84.10 <.0001*
T1RA T1T2* 54.88 26.18 83.59 <.0001*
T1FA T1T2* 50.81 22.11 79.51 <.0001*
T2*FA T1T2* 46.78 18.08 75.49 <.0001*
T2*RA T2* 45.31 16.61 74.01 0.0001*
T1RD T1T2* 45.17 16.47 73.87 0.0001*
T1RA T2* 44.79 16.09 73.49 0.0002*
T1E0 T1T2* 42.62 13.92 71.32 0.0004*
T2*RD T1T2* 41.05 12.35 69.75 0.001*
T1FA T2* 40.72 12.02 69.42 0.001*
T2*E0 T1T2* 38.13 9.43 66.83 0.002*
T1Tr T1T2* 37.77 9.07 66.47 0.002*
T2*FA T2* 36.69 7.99 65.40 0.004*
T1RD T2* 35.08 6.37 63.78 0.006*
T2*Tr T1T2* 33.87 5.17 62.58 0.009*
T1 T1T2* 32.59 3.88 61.29 0.01*
T1E0 T2* 32.53 3.82 61.23 0.01*
T2*RD T2* 30.96 2.25 59.66 0.02*
T2*E0 T2* 28.04 −0.66 56.74 0.06
T1Tr T2* 27.68 −1.03 56.38 0.07
cc
T2*RA T2*Tr 26.13 2.08 50.17 0.02*
T1RA T2*Tr 25.08 1.03 49.12 0.03*
T2*FA T2*Tr 24.90 0.85 48.94 0.04*
T1FA T2*Tr 22.66 −1.39 46.71 0.08
Brain rest
T1RA T2* 2.30 0.60 4.01 0.002*
T2*RA T2* 2.24 0.53 3.95 0.003*
T2*FA T2* 2.07 0.36 3.78 0.01*
T1E0 T2* 1.82 0.11 3.53 0.03*
T1RD T2* 1.82 0.11 3.53 0.03*
T1RA T1 1.77 0.06 3.48 0.04*
T2*RA T1 1.70 −0.01 3.41 0.05
T1Tr T2* 1.63 −0.08 3.34 0.08
T2*E0 T2* 1.57 −0.14 3.28 0.10
C
Multichannel segmentation in test strains showed that T1 and T1T2w combinations have similar performance, and outperformed T2w in segmenting the cc (T1 vs T2w: CI [4.7 81.9]; T2w vs T1T2w: CI [−81.6 −4.3]) and VS (T1 vs T2w: CI [4.7 85.8]; T2w vs T1T2w: CI [−83.8 −2.7]).
T1 (%) T2(%) T1T2w (%) F P
Brain rest 90.60±1.07 89.92±1.14 90.76±1.03 0.02 0.98
Hc 79.95±2.27 72.02±3.18 80.04±2.42 0.07 0.93
CPu 83.08±1.41 79.07±1.03 83.82±1.45 0.18 0.84
SN 48.63±5.11 53.69±3.88 54.70±5.00 0.04 0.96
ac 39.14±3.97 29.28±4.25 39.74±3.35 0.64 0.54
cc 53.67±3.32 39.14±2.88 53.57±3.36 5.29 0.01*
VS 46.42±2.41 31.75±3.54 44.07±3.01 5.05 0.02*
D
For C57BL/6 miceMRF classification following deformable registration (Diff), using T2* and RA images outperformed Diff only (using T2* and RA images), and differences were significant in 5 out of 8 structures labeled.
C57BL/6 Diff(%) MRF(%) Difference (%) t CI1 CI2 p
Brain rest 95.97±0.70 95.13±0.63 −0.84 −0.89 −2.94 1.26 0.39
Hc 91.39±0.39 93.61±0.28 2.22 4.65 1.16 3.29 0.001*
CPu 88.82±0.60 92.02±0.54 3.2 3.99 1.41 4.99 0.003*
SN 72.56±2.35 80.86±1.12 8.3 3.18 2.49 14.11 0.01*
ac 74.90±3.18 77.59±5.17 2.69 0.44 −10.83 16.21 0.67
cc 73.47±1.86 79.96±1.75 6.49 2.54 0.8 12.18 0.03*
LV 62.65±3.29 73.92±3.13 11.26 2.48 1.14 21.38 0.03*
V4 56.92±5.55 63.30±5.55 6.39 0.81 −11.11 23.88 0.44
E
For test strains there was a trend for MRF classification following deformable registration (Diff) to outperform Diff, with the exception of the ac, which was not reliably segmented.
Test strains Diff (%) MRF (%) Difference (%) t CI1 CI2 p
Brain rest 90.76±0.42 90.12±0.30 −0.64 1.24 −1.57 2.85 0.34
Hc 80.04±1.88 87.37±1.91 7.32 −2.74 −18.84 4.19 0.11
CPu 83.82±1.15 86.23±4.61 2.41 −0.51 −22.87 18.05 0.66
SN 54.70±4.74 66.62±3.64 11.92 −1.99 −37.64 13.80 0.18
ac 39.74±1.98 16.83±1.69 −22.90 8.79 11.69 34.11 0.01
cc 53.57±6.51 59.81±6.77 6.24 −0.66 −46.64 34.16 0.57
VS 44.07±7.15 53.08±16.12 9.01 −0.51 −84.87 66.85 0.66
*

indicates significance at a p<0.05 level