Skip to main content
. 2013 Feb 13;3(3):676–693. doi: 10.1002/ece3.475

Table 2.

Summary of two-way ANOVAs followed by Tukey HSD post hoc tests testing the effect of pCO2 and temperature on Lithophyllum cabiochae metabolism in the dark and at the culture irradiance levels and Chl a content at each season

ANOVA data

Source of variation Tukey HSD test


pCO2 temperature pCO2 × temperature



df F P F P F P 400 T 400 T+3 700 T 700 T+3
Summer
 Dark
  Rd (O2) (1,16) 0.030 0.864 0.085 0.775 6.864 0.019 nd
  Rd (CO2) (1,16) 0.153 0.700 0.320 0.579 1.820 0.196 nd
  Gd (CaCO3) (1,16) 0.432 0.520 8.749 0.009 6.913 0.018 a b ab ab
 Light
  Pn (O2) (1,16) 33.977 <0.001 6.524 0.021 1.390 0.256 a a ab b
  Pn (CO2) (1,16) 41.200 <0.001 10.160 0.006 2.610 0.126 a a ab b
  Pg (O2) (1,16) 17.983 <0.001 4.243 0.056 3.853 0.067 a a ab b
  Pg (CO2) (1,16) 13.216 0.002 2.747 0.117 3.304 0.088 a a ab b
  G (CaCO3) (1,16) 8.346 0.011 2.743 0.117 24.690 <0.001 a ab b a
Chl a (1,16) 0.017 0.897 2.895 0.108 0.617 0.444 nd
Autumn
 Dark
  Rd (O2) (1,16) 3.552 0.078 7.136 0.017 0.595 0.452 nd
  Rd (CO2) (1,16) 0.035 0.853 12.203 0.003 0.448 0.513 nd
  Gd (CaCO3) (1,16) 0.369 0.552 0.000 0.984 2.824 0.112 nd
 Light
  Pn (O2) (1,16) 28.611 <0.001 7.489 0.015 0.139 0.714 a a ab b
  Pn (CO2) (1,16) 10.830 0.005 4.921 0.041 3.157 0.095 a ab b b
  Pg (O2) (1,16) 17.108 <0.001 0.211 0.652 0.039 0.846 nd
  Pg (CO2) (1,16) 7.219 0.017 1.141 0.301 0.792 0.387 nd
  G (CaCO3) (1,16) 0.167 0.689 8.167 0.011 8.167 0.011 ab ab a b
Chl a (1,16) 1.009 0.330 0.646 0.433 0.091 0.767 nd
Winter
 Dark
  Rd (O2) (1,15) 0.257 0.619 18.389 <0.001 0.938 0.348 ab a b a
  Rd (CO2) (1,15) 2.834 0.113 2.262 0.153 1.311 0.270 nd
  Gd (CaCO3) (1,15) 0.017 0.898 3.794 0.070 0.676 0.424 nd
 Light
  Pn (O2) (1,15) 62.325 <0.001 7.310 0.016 0.469 0.503 a a b b
  Pn (CO2) (1,15) 48.847 <0.001 0.555 0.468 3.976 0.065 a a b b
  Pg (O2) (1,15) 51.721 <0.001 1.056 0.321 0.000 1.000 a a b b
  Pg (CO2) (1,15) 27.699 <0.001 5.228 0.037 1.082 0.315 ab a b b
  G (CaCO3) (1,15) 0.344 0.566 12.396 0.003 0.344 0.566 nd
Chl a (1,15) 0.350 0.563 3.963 0.074 1.071 0.317 nd
Spring
 Dark
  Rd (O2) (1,15) 0.096 0.761 6.869 0.019 3.565 0.078 nd
  Rd (CO2) (1,15) 0.126 0.728 3.142 0.097 0.005 0.944 nd
  Gd (CaCO3) (1,15) 0.609 0.447 1.007 0.332 0.311 0.585 nd
 Light
  Pn (O2) (1,15) 3.371 0.086 0.090 0.768 2.703 0.121 nd
  Pn (CO2) (1,15) 0.143 0.711 0.548 0.470 17.780 0.001 a b ab ab
  Pg (O2) (1,15) 4.235 0.057 0.448 0.514 4.661 0.047 nd
  Pg (CO2) (1,15) 0.017 0.898 3.625 0.076 12.398 0.003 a b ab ab
  G (CaCO3) (1,15) 1.734 0.208 0.444 0.515 7.864 0.013 nd
Chl a (1,15) 0.024 0.880 4.575 0.049 0.062 0.807 nd

Rd, dark respiration; Pn, net production; Pg, gross production; Gd, net calcification in the dark; G, net calcification in the light. Bold type indicates Bonferroni-adjusted significance (P < 0.0125). Different letters (a and b) indicate significant difference between treatments: 400 T, 400 T + 3, 700 T, and 700 T + 3 (P < 0.0125, Tukey's HSD test); nd, no difference.