Skip to main content
. 2013 Mar 1;4(2):115–118. doi: 10.4161/bioe.22350

Table 1. Comparison of polyhydroxyalkanoates extraction methods6.

Extraction method Advantages Disadvantages
 
 
 
Solvent extraction
Elimination of endotoxin/high purity
Break PHA granules morphology
 
No polymer degradation
Hazards connected with halogenated solvents
 
 
High price/Low recovery
Digestion by surfactants
Treatment of high cell densities
Low purity/Water waste
 
No polymer degradation
treatment needed
Digestion by NaOCl
High purity
Degradation of the polymer
Digestion by NaOCl and chloroform
Low polymer degradation/ high purity
High quantity of solvent needed
Digestion by NaOCl and surfactants
Limited degradation/low operating cost
 
Digestion by chelate and surfactants
High purity/low environmental pollution
Large volume of wastewater
 
 
Low degradation of the polymer
Selective dissolution of NPCM
High recovery and purity, low operating costs
 
Enzymatic digestion
Good recovery
High costs of enzymes
Bead mill disruption
No chemicals used
Require several passes
High pressure homogenization
No chemicals used
Poor disruption rate for low biomass levels
 
 
Low micronization
Supercritical CO2
Low cost and toxicity
Low recovery
Using cell fragility
Use of weak extracting conditions
 
Air classification
High purity
Low recovery
Dissolved air flotation
No chemicals used
Require several consecutive flotation steps
Spontaneous liberation No extracting chemicals needed Low recovery