Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Mar 29.
Published in final edited form as: J Am Coll Cardiol. 2011 Feb 15;57(7):794–801. doi: 10.1016/j.jacc.2010.09.064

Table 2.

Case Ascertainment Criteria and Sources

Case ascertainment criteria
Source Time Geograph
y
Disease
Attributio
n
Witnessed
or
Unwitness
ed
Age SCA
include
d
Sources for case ascertainment
Gillum,
RF(13)
Not
specified
Out-of-
hospital or
in the
emergenc
y room
Ischemic
heart
disease
Not
specified
≥25
years
old
no 1) National Center for Health Statistics
(NCHS) data from the 40 states that reported
data
2) US standard certificate of death, item 7c*

Escobedo,
et al.(14)
≤ 1 hr of
onset of
cardio-
vascular
symptoms
Not
specified
Coronary
heart
disease
Not
specified
≥25
years
old
no 1) 1986 National Mortality Followback Survey
(did not include data from Oregon or patients <
25 years old)
2) 1980 US Bureau of the Census data
3) Death certificates (death considered to have
resulted from coronary heart disease if death
certificate listed rubrics 410 through 414
International Classification of Diseases, 9th
revision)
4) Additional information obtained through
questionnaire/interview of person identified as
the informant on death certificate (89% of
informants responded)

Zheng, et
al.(17)
≤1 hour of
symptoms
Out-of-
hospital or
in the
emergenc
y room or
“dead on
arrival”
with
underlying
cause of
death
reported
as cardiac
disease
Cardiac
disease
death
Not
specified
≥ 35
years
old
no 1) NCHS data
2) Death certificates (death considered to have
resulted from cardiac disease if underlying
cause of death classified using ICD-9 codes
390–398, 402, or 404–429)

Cobb, et
al.(15)
Not
specified
Out-of-
hospital
Cardiac
cause
Witnessed
or
unwitnesse
d
≥ 20
years
old
no 1)Medical incident reports submitted by fire
department paramedics for all patients who
received advanced life support by Seattle Fire
Department/EMS personnel
2) Any missing data from above obtained from
death certificates or hospital admission forms*

Chugh, et
al,.
2004(16)
and
Chugh, et
al.,
2008(19)
≤1 hour of
symptoms
if
witnessed
or ≤24 hrs
if
unwitness
ed
Not
specified
Cardiac
cause
Witnessed
or
unwitnesse
d
No age
criteria
yes 1) Case ascertainment from EMS system
(78%), county medical examiner’s office
(20%), and 16 area hospitals (2%). Of 353
cases, 280 identified by EMS; 68 by medical
examiner; and 5 by hospital or provider
2) Postmortem exam performed at discretion
of medical examiner or physician
3) Death certificate data from Oregon State
Health Division
4) Available medical records

Nichol, et
al.,
2008(18)
Not
specified
Out-of-
hospital
Cardiac
cause
Not
specified
No age
criteria
(infants
,
childre
n, and
adults
all
include
d)
yes 1) Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium (ROC),
a clinical research network consisting of 11
sites and 1 central coordinating center,
conducting clinical research on
cardiopulmonary arrest and traumatic injury.
ROC created a registry, ROC Epistry-Cardiac
Arrest, which is a prospective, multicenter,
observational registry of out-of-hospital arrests
in EMS agencies and 11 institutions (8 US, 3
Canadian)
2) Multiple case ascertainment strategies used:
telephone notification of each incident
defibrillator use or CPR by EMS, hand sorting
through paper EMS charts, electronic queries
of EMS records using various data fields such
as dispatch type, vital signs, or diagnosis,

CPR = cardiopulmonary resuscitation; EMS = emergency medical services; ICD = International Classification of Diseases

*

% of data from each source not provided

The National Mortality Followback Survey is described as a random sample of 1% of U.S. resident deaths (except residents of Oregon) age 25 years or older in 1986(27).