Table 4.
DSM-IV Symptom Dimension |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Samplesa |
Inattention |
Hyp - Imp |
Difference between dimensionsd |
||
Construct | kb | Total N | r [95% CI] | r [95% CI] | |
Anxiety disorders | |||||
Generalized Anxiety Disorder | 13 | 21,204 | .45 [.38, .52]*e | .44 [.38, .49]*e | ns |
Separation Anxiety Disorder | 14 | 12,490 | .20 [.13, .27]*e | .24 [.16, .32]*e | ns |
Social phobia | 4 | 5,474 | .28 [.16, .40]*e | .20 [.04, .34]*e | ns |
Mood Disorders | |||||
Withdrawn | 17 | 6,793 | .28 [.24, .32]* | .09 [.03, .15]*e | Inatt > Hyp-imp |
Depression | 17 | 19,601 | .40 [.35, .44]*e | .29 [.23, .34]*e | Inatt > Hyp-imp |
Other Internalizing | |||||
Anxious / Depressed | 14 | 9,063 | .27 [.23, .32]*e | .26 [.22, .29]* | ns |
Somatic Complaints | 14 | 2,829 | .19 [.15, .22]* | .13 [.10, .17]* | ns |
Total Internalizing | 13 | 4,154 | .32 [.28, .36]* | .23 [.17, .29]* | Inatt > Hyp-imp |
Disruptive disorders | |||||
Oppositional Defiant Disorder | 29 | 41,363 | .54 [.50, .58]*e | .65 [.61, .69]*e | Hyp-Imp > Inatt |
Conduct Problems | 25 | 31,326 | .38 [.33, .43]*e | .47 [.42, .53]*e | Hyp-Imp > Inatt |
Aggressive Behavior | 19 | 7,189 | .37 [.33, .41]*e,f | .57 [.54, .60]*e | Hyp-Imp > Inatt |
Delinquent Behavior | 15 | 5,175 | .28 [.23, .33]*e,f | .33 [.28, .38]*e | ns |
Total Externalizing | 13 | 5,774 | .43 [.36, .50]*e | .59 [.54, .63]*e | Hyp-Imp > Inatt |
Other symptoms | |||||
Pervasive Developmental Dis. | 6 | 2,449 | .35 [.26, .43]*e | .27 [.13, .40]*e | ns |
Note. Supplement Table 9 includes the complete list of effect sizes and a summary of tests for publication bias and heterogeneity among the effects.
k = number of effect sizes included in the summary statistic.
Overall weighted correlation based on a random-effects model (DerSimonian & Laird, 1986).
Overall correlations are significantly different (P < .05).
significant heterogeneity among the effects (see Supplement Table 9).
after correction for publication bias correlations were slightly higher between inattention and delinquent behavior (r = .34), and aggressive behavior (r = .42).
= P < .05.