Skip to main content
. 2013 Mar 20;13:135. doi: 10.1186/1471-2407-13-135

Table 5.

Methodological quality of included studies - part two

Author, yr Reliability Measurement error Hypothesis testing Criterion validity Responsiveness
Functional capacity
 
 
 
 
 
Brunelli 2012 [43]
x
x
x
Fair
x
England 2012 [44]
x
x
Fair
x
x
Jones 2012 [40]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Brunelli 2010 [31]
x
x
Excellent
x
x
Pancieri 2010 [22]
x
x
x
Fair
x
Kasymjanova 2009 [25]
x
x
x
Fair
x
Brunelli 2008a [34]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Brunelli 2008b [33]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Koegelenberg 2008 [29]
x
x
x
Fair
x
Nikolic 2008 [36]
x
x
x
Poor
x
Brunelli 2007 [20]
x
x
Fair
x
x
Mao 2007 [26]
x
x
Fair
Good
x
Saad 2007 [24]
x
x
x
Poor
x
Toker 2007 [37]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Win 2006 [30]
x
x
Fair
Good
x
Brunelli 2005 [42]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Brunelli 2004 [35]
x
x
x
Good
x
Win 2004 [64]
x
x
Poor
Poor
x
Brunelli 2003 [21]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Parsons 2003 [39]
x
x
x
Good
x
Brunelli 2002 [32]
x
x
x
Excellent
x
Pate 1996 [38]
x
x
x
Poor
x
Pierce 1994 [23]
x
x
x
Poor
x
Holden 1992 [41]
x
x
x
Poor
x
Physical activity
 
 
 
 
 
Maddocks 2012 [47]
x
x
Poor
x
x
Novoa 2011 [51]
x
x
Poor
x
x
Grutsch 2011a, 2011b; Du-Quiton 2010 [48-50]
x
x
Fair
x
x
Maddocks 2010 [46]
x
x
Fair
x
x
Muscle strength
 
 
 
x
x
Trutschnigg 2008 [28]
Poor (intra-r)
x
x
x
x
Brown 2005 [53]
x
x
Fair
x
x
Knols 2002 [52] Fair (inter-r) Fair x x x

Abbreviations: inter-r, inter-rater reliability; intra-r, intra-rater reliability; yr, year published.

x = not assessed.