Table 5.
OSATS | Multimedia-based training | Practical training | Combination training | Control group |
---|---|---|---|---|
Task-specific checklista | (n = 18) | (n = 17) | (n = 18) | (n = 17) |
1. Placement of trocars | 100→100 | 88→100 | 89→100 | 88→94 |
2. Exploration of the liver and display of the anatomic landmarks | 94→100 | 88→82 | 89→100 | 82→64 |
3. Fixation of the infundibulum | 50→100 | 47→82 | 56→100 | 47→71 |
4. Incision of the peritoneal layer on the infundibulum | 44→100 | 47→82 | 44→100 | 17→70 |
5. Exposure of the cystic duct and cystic artery | 33→100 | 23→58 | 28→72 | 17→23 |
6. Clipping of the cystic duct | 61→100 | 41→59 | 39→89 | 53→53 |
7. Cutting of the cystic duct | 56→100 | 35→70 | 44→89 | 53→47 |
8. Clipping of the cystic artery | 17→78 | 23→41 | 22→66 | 17→17 |
9. Cutting the cystic artery | 17→78 | 23→35 | 22→66 | 17→17 |
10. Subserous shelling out of the gallbladder | 88→94 | 47→71 | 55→94 | 53→59 |
11. Inspection of the liver bed | 39→89 | 23→35 | 33→89 | 41→23 |
12. Recovery of the gallbladder in the salvage bag | 55→83 | 59→83 | 61→78 | 64→88 |
aTask-specific checklist data for each procedural step for all four groups: the first number is the pretest value and the number after the arrow is the posttest value