Table 1.
Randomized Comparisons of Allogeneic PBSC v. BM
Total No. Pts | % Patients with Advanced Disease4 | Stem Cell Source | Engraftment: Median Day to: | Acute GVHD % | Chronic GVHD % | DFS3 % | Survival % | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Neutrophils5 00/ul | Platelets 20,000/ul | Grade II–IV | Grade III–IV | |||||||
[19] | 101 | 5 | PBSC BM |
15* 21 |
13* 21 |
44 42 |
17 23 |
50* 28 |
58 62 |
61 61 |
[20] | 611 | 28 | PBSC BM |
17* 23 |
13* 21 |
25 10 |
NR | 55 26 |
85 65 |
82 75 |
[21] [22] |
56 | 32 | PBSC BM |
15* 18 |
12* 18 |
26 23 |
13 13 |
77* 61 |
60 50 |
56 48 |
[23] | 30 | NR2 | PBSC BM |
9* 25 |
10* 30 |
7 40 |
7 40 |
NR | NR | NR |
[24] [25] |
329 | 14 | PBSC BM |
12* 15 |
15* 20 |
52* 39* |
28* 16 |
74* 53 |
425 45 |
495 57 |
[26] | 39 | 46 | PBSC BM |
17* 23 |
11* 19 |
50 47 |
NR | 44 40 |
NR | 70 63 |
[27] | 2281 | 27 | PBSC BM |
19* 22 |
16* 22 |
40 40 |
NR | 71 55 |
NR | 68* 60 |
[28] [29] |
172 | 47 | PBSC BM |
16* 21 |
13* 19 |
64 57 |
15 12 |
48 38 |
655* 45 |
585 56 |
6 donor-recipients were 5/6 antigen matches
NR = not reported
DFS = disease -free survival
Advanced disease = CML >CP, Acute leukemias >1st CR, Lymphomas >2nd CR, RAEB(T), multiple myeloma
10 year outcomes
= statistically significant