Table 1.
Study | Design | Sample size | Documented average cervical length (mm) |
Mean gestational age (weeks) cerclage | Cerclage type | Progesterone type | Total duration of progesterone therapy (weeks) | Gestational age (weeks) delivery | Outcome | Overall rate of PTB |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sherman 1966, [2] | Observational cohort* | 33/540 | n/a | Variable | Both | 17-αOHPC IM | Variable to 36 | 39.3 | LB | n/a |
| ||||||||||
Vitoratos et al., 1996 [3] | Prospective cohort | 8/18 | n/a | 14-15 | Shirodkar | OHP IM† |
Preoperative one dose | >37 | PTB < 37 wga | 6% (<37)†† |
| ||||||||||
Zakut and Lanciano, 1981 [4] | Retrospective cohort | 30/60 | 14 ± 4.5 | 14.6 ± 2.83 | Both | 17-αOHPC IM | 15 | n/a | PTB < 24 wga hospitalization BW Apgar score |
13.3% (<24) |
| ||||||||||
Berghella et al., 2010 [5] | Retrospective cohort | 47/148 | 19.0 | 18.9 | McDonald | 17-αOHPC IM |
From 16 to 36 | Not reported | PTB < 37 wga PTB < 35 wga PTB < 32 wga PTB < 28 wga PTB < 24 wga PM |
49% (<37) 30% (<35) 17% (<32) 9% (<28) 4% (<24) |
| ||||||||||
Rafael et al., 2011 [6] | Retrospective cohort | 15/58 | 18 (12–22) | 21 (16–22) | n/a | 17-αOHPC IM | From 16–20 to 36 | 35 (27-28) | PTB < 35 wga PTB < 32 wga PTB < 28 wga BW |
40% (<35) 33.3% (<32) 33.3% (<28) |
| ||||||||||
Rebarber et al., 2008 [7] | Retrospective cohort | 232/1882 | n/a | n/a | n/a | 17-αOHPC IM | 13.5 ± 5 | 35.4 ± 4.7 | PTB < 37 wga PTB < 35 wga PTB < 32 wga |
40.5% (<37) 25.9% (<32) 13.4% (<32) |
n/a: not available, 17-αOHPC: 17-alpha-hydroxyprogesterone acetate, IM: intramuscular, wga: weeks gestational age, PTB: preterm birth, LB: live birth, BW: birth weight, and PM: perinatal death (stillbirth or postnatal death prior to hospital discharge).
*Unable to specify based on the review of an article whether the observational study was prospective or retrospective in nature.
†This agent was reported as hydroxyprogesterone hexanoate.
††Did not specify whether PTB was in progesterone plus cerclage treatment group.