Table 6.
№ | The models behavior | Experimental observations by Bentele et al. and predictions of the models |
---|---|---|
1 |
|
Experiments by Bentele et al.: |
|
|
− for 1 ng/ml of anti-CD95, PARP cleavage was not observed; |
|
|
− the measured death rate for 10 ng/ml of anti-CD95 was 20-30%. |
|
|
Original model (red): |
|
|
− the apoptotic threshold is 1.9 ng/ml; |
|
|
− cPARP concentration rises dramatically within an extremely narrow interval of anti-CD95 levels overcoming the apoptotic threshold. |
|
|
Composite model (blue): |
|
|
− the apoptotic threshold is 3.5 ng/ml; |
|
|
− cPARP concentration rises in a smooth manner along with the increase of anti-CD95 level. |
2 |
|
Experiments by Bentele et al.: down-regulation of cFLIP in SKW 6.4 cells by addition of cyclohexamide resulted in cell death (40% for 1 day) already upon 1 ng/ml of anti-CD95. The level of cFLIP was decreased to 70%. |
|
|
Original (red) and composite (blue) models: |
|
|
− the apoptotic threshold is highly sensitive to the concentration of cFLIP; |
|
|
− decreasing the initial concentration of cFLIP by more than 51% and 49% for the original and composite models, respectively, leads to cell death upon stimulation by 1 ng/ml of anti-CD95. |
3 |
|
Experiments by Bentele et al.: in the 10 ng/ml activation scenario, a significant increase of caspase-8 was observed after more than 4 hours. |
|
|
Original (red) and composite (blue) models: anti-CD95 concentrations which are slightly above the apoptotic threshold result in caspase-8 activation after a delay of many hours. |
|
|
The figure shows peak times of caspase-8 concentration exceeding 0.1% of the initial procaspase-8 level. |
4 |
|
Original model: |
|
|
− low concentrations of IAP (less than 1 nM) result in complete cell death; |
|
|
− high concentrations of IAP prevent a significant increase of caspase-3 even for high concentrations of the ligand. |
|
|
Composite model: |
|
|
− low concentrations of IAP (less than 1 nM) block apoptosis for CD95L less than 0.3 nM; |
|
|
− high concentrations of CD95L lead to cell death. |
The figures show logarithmic dependence of the maximal caspases-3 concentration on initial values of IAP and CD95L. |
The simulation time was 2880 min (2 days) in all predictions. The apoptotic threshold in the prediction 1 is the concentration of anti-CD95 after which cPARP amount exceeds 10% of the initial PARP level.