Appendix A.
Authors; Year of Publication; Setting; Study Design | Sample | Purpose; Study Protocol/Measures | Results |
---|---|---|---|
Tamragouri et al., 1986 USA Cross-sectional, comparative study |
Group One: 69 freshmen with a FH of CVD; 55% female Group Two: 155 freshmen without a FH; 50.6% female Mean age of sample and race/ethnicity not provided |
To compare the cardiovascular health knowledge and health behaviors between college freshmen with and without a FH of CVD Questionnaires with Iowa Cardiovascular Health Knowledge Test, demographics, family characteristics, selected health behaviors, and efforts to acquire health information |
Cardiovascular Health Knowledge was low in both groups (18 of 35 questions were incorrectly answered by at least 40% of each group) with no differences between the two groups Students with a FH exercised less (OR=0.38; 90% CI: 0.16-.0.91) and were more likely to feel overweight (OR=1.73; 90% CI: 1.02–2.94) compared to students without a FH Students with a FH were not more likely to eat a low-fat diet (OR=1.85; 90% CI: 0.79–4.35), made no extra effort to receive health education (OR=1.21; 90% CI: 0.90–1.62), were more likely to smoke (OR=1.22; 90% CI: 0.61–1.62), and were less likely to have their cholesterol measured (OR=0.63; 90% CI: 0.29–1.38) compared to students without a FH Note: These differences were not statistically significant |
Brorsson et al., 1995 Sweden Qualitative study |
63 male participants, 35–45 year-old, diagnosed with moderate hypercholesterolemia (6.5–7.7 mmol/l) | To study the traits and relationship between FH and perceived risk in males with moderate hypercholesterolemia Lifestyle counseling session were audio-taped, transcribed and analyzed Session occurred after participants were newly diagnosed |
45% (n=28) mentioned their FH during the counseling session 9% (n=6) specifically mentioned that CHD was part of their FH Fatal events, non-fatal conditions (symptoms of CHD), and premature deaths also emerged as themes that influenced perceived risk Note: The authors assumed that the participants perceived themselves at risk after the diagnosis of hypercholesterolemia (actual perceived risk was not measured) |
Marteau et el.; 1995 United Kingdom Baseline, descriptive data from an RCT |
3725 participants screened as part of the British Family Heart Study 2246 men (mean age of 50.11) and 1604 (mean age of 47.8) women Race/ethnicity not provided |
To examine how individuals perceived their risk for CHD prior to screening To assess the degree of similarity between perceived risk and epidemiologically derived risk score Self-assessed 15-year heart attack risk “… compared with other people of your age and sex?” Epidemiologically-assessed risk based on: years smoking cigarettes, systolic BP, cholesterol level, diagnosis of CHD, diabetes, angina, and FH |
Perceived Risk
|
Ponder et al., 1996 United Kingdom Descriptive study |
58 teenagers (23 males and 35 females; mean age of 16.8; range 16–18) 54 of their parents (19 fathers and 35 mothers, with a mean age of 46.5, range 36–74) |
To examine the extent to which people take account FH when considering their susceptibility to health risks Interviews with teenagers and parents; same protocol for both Two-part interview:
|
Perceived risk
|
Allen & Blumenthal, 1998 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
87 apparently healthy off-spring (56 daughters and 31 sons) of women with premature CHD Mean age of 37 (SD ± 7 years), 72% Caucasian |
To examine coronary risk factors, related knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs concerning CHD risk Questionnaires, physical examination, and CHD risk biomarkers |
Risk Factors
|
Ayanian & Cleary, 1999 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
737 current smokers (54.6% female; 83.7% Caucasian) Mean age 42.6 |
To assess smokers perceived risk for MI Self-reported smoking status and numbers of cigarettes smoked daily Self-assessed risk compared to people of the same age and sex |
Only 29% of smokers perceived their MI risk as higher than persons of the same age and sex Among smokers with a FH of MI, 39% viewed their risk as higher than persons of the same age and sex |
Hunt et al., 2000 United Kingdom Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
Three cohorts originally recruited in 1987/88 The youngest cohort was around 23 years old (n = 676), the middle cohort was around 43 years old (n = 754), and the oldest cohort was around 63 (n = 732) Majority of the study participants were female (53% in the youngest cohort, 56.1% in the middle cohort, and 55.7% in the oldest cohort) |
To examined the relationship between FH of HD and health-related attitudes and behavior Data used in the study were collected in 1995/96 Nurses collected information designed to explore the relationship between perceptions of FH of illness, health attitudes, health-related behaviors, and asked questions about the health and deaths of family members |
FH
|
Kavanagh et al., 2000 Canada Cross-sectional, descriptive study with a 2 year follow-up questionnaire |
571 sons of men with a premature coronary event Mean age 32.1 (SD ± 7.1) Race/ethnicity not provided |
To determine the modifiable risk factors in the male offspring of patients who had a premature coronary event To assess the extent of personal health initiatives being taken by the offspring To estimate, from the perspective of the offspring, the degree to which their family physicians had promoted a healthy lifestyle and carried out risk-reduction counseling Questionnaires: medical history, lifestyle, knowledge of health status and risk factors, and interaction with the family physician Lipid panel drawn |
Risk Factors
|
Hunt et al., 2001 United Kingdom Qualitative study |
Purposive sampling of 61 men and women who participated in the 1996 Midspan Family Study “Roughly equal numbers of men and women from middle class and working class” Between the ages of 40–49 during the 1996 survey |
To explore which factors affect whether people regard themselves as having a FH of CHD or not Semi-structured interviews Questions in the interviews covered why some people have more illnesses than others, beliefs about HD, FH of illness or weaknesses, construction of FH tree, and discussion of inheritance in the broadest sense |
Genes, or heredity, were mentioned as a cause of HD by more than two-thirds of the respondents Perception of a FH of HD depended on knowledge of the health of family members, the number and closeness of relatives with heart conditions, and the age of affected relatives Women usually gave more detailed accounts than men and needed less encouragement Men, particularly working-class men, required a greater number of close relatives to be affected to perceive that they had a FH Even when respondents judged that HD ran in their family, they did not always perceive themselves as at increased risk because they felt different in crucial ways from their affected relatives |
Kip et al., 2002 United States Longitudinal, descriptive study |
3950 participants; 77% of total cohort originally approximately equally distributed by age, race/ethnicity, gender, and education | To examine if the occurrence of a heart attack or stroke in an immediate family member had an impact on CVD risk factors in young adults Smoking, physical activity, lipids/lipoproteins, body weight, and blood pressure were recorded over two consecutive 5-year follow-up periods Occurrence of a heart attack or stroke in an immediate family member of the participants was recorded between Year 0 (baseline) and Year 5 and between Year 5 and Year 10 |
After adjusting for baseline demographics and risk factors, young adults who experienced a change in FH of heart attack or stroke over a 5-year period were no more likely to quit smoking or to experience more positive changes in weight, physical activity, LDL cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, triglycerides, or systolic or diastolic BP compared to young adults without a change in their FH |
Montgomery et al., 2003 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
522 participants; 62% female and 56% Caucasian Mean age: 39.61 (SD ± 15.29) |
To examined if a FH of disease contributes to perceived risk, if a history of disease in a friend or non-blood relative increases perceived risk, and if these effects are similar across genders Participants completed a Health Assessment Personal Protocol Inventory, which included items to assess demographic variables, perceived risk, personal and FH of HD Participants were also asked if they had a friend or non-blood relative with each disease (Friend History) |
For both men and women, a positive FH of HD was associated with higher levels of perceived risk for HD (p<0.0001) Women only: a positive history of HD in a friend was associated with higher levels of perceived risk for HD (p<0.0001) |
Astin & Jones, 2004 Australia Descriptive study |
141 subjects (108 males) Mean age 63 (SD ± 10.9) 90% European ethnicity |
To compare patients’ perceived causal attributions for CHD between males and females Semi-structured interviews to elicited information about causal attributions; BMI was recorded at the time of the interview Data about coronary risk factors were extracted from the medical records |
Women more frequently cited FH as the cause of their CHD (41% vs. 28%; p=.001) A greater proportion of males than females attributed their illness to behavioral (controllable) causes rather than to biological causes (51% vs. 23%; p<.001) A greater proportion of females than males attributed their illness to biological (uncontrollable) causes (42% vs. 24%; p=.04) |
Kelley et al., 2004 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive, comparative study |
297 participants from the Coronary Artery Risk Detection in Appalachian Communities (CARDIAC) Project All participants were Caucasian, 53% were female, the average age was 10.8 (SD ± 0.6) years for boys and 10.6 (SD ± 0.7) years for girls |
To examine if children who were at high-risk for CVD based on FH would have different diets than children from low-risk families All participants were screened for FH of early CVD; had their height, weight, and fingerstick total cholesterol measured; and filled out a 151-item food frequency questionnaires |
Children at risk for CVD
|
McCusker et al. 2004 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
3383 respondents without a personal history of stroke, heart attack, angina, or CHD 63% were female, 75% were Caucasian, 35% were between the ages of 35–44, and 36% were between the ages of 45–64 |
To examine the association between FH–based HD risk and CVD risk-reducing behaviors Data from the 2001 Healthstyles survey, a cross-sectional survey of health attitudes, behaviors, conditions, and knowledge, was used The authors compared individuals with no reported FH of CVD (average risk) to individuals with one reported relative with a history of CVD (moderate risk) and individuals with two or more reported relatives with a history of CVD (high risk) |
Risk Classification
|
DeSalvo et al., 2005 United States Baseline, descriptive data from an RCT |
128 African American women Mean age 56 (range 35 to 86) |
To describe the personal characteristics associated with underestimating CVD in black women Objective risk was determined by counting major cardiac risk factors Perceived risk determined by a survey question about personal cardiac risk |
This sample had a high prevalence of cardiac risk factors: 77% were obese; 72% had hypertension; 48% had high cholesterol; 49% had a FH of heart disease; 31% had diabetes, and 22% currently used tobacco Seventy-nine percent had 3 or more cardiac risk factors and were at high risk; 63% of these individuals did not perceived themselves to be at risk for HD Among all patients, objective and perceived cardiac risk was poorly correlated |
Walter & Emery, 2005 & 2006 Qualitative study |
30 participants (53% females) 40% of were between 20–39 years old, 47% were between 40–59 years old, and 13% were older than 60 years old 93% were Caucasian and 87% married 50% had a FH of heart disease, 47% had a FH of cancer, and 23% had a FH of diabetes |
To explore how individuals understand and come to terms with their FH Interviews were conducted with general practice patients who had a FH of cancer, HD, or diabetes The recorded and transcribed data underwent a qualitative constant comparative analysis |
Feeling at risk
|
Thanavaro et al., 2006 United States Correlational cross-sectional design |
119 women Mean age 49.4 (SD ± 6.7) 78% Caucasian |
To determine HPB and the best predictors of HPB in women without prior history of CHD Study measures: demographic information, perceived CVD risk factors, HPLP II, CHD knowledge, the Benefits Scale, and the Barriers Scale |
The sample did not practice HPB regularly (based on the HPLP II) and had low CHD knowledge levels, a high perception level of benefits, and a moderate level of perceived barriers to CHD risk modification Backward multiple regression analysis demonstrated that FH of CHD (p=.05), CHD knowledge levels (p=.005) and perceived barriers to CHD risk modification (p<.001) were the best predictors of HPB in women without CHD |
Patel et al., 2007 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive, comparative study as part of the Dallas Heart Study |
2404 subjects (1327 women and 1077 men) between the ages of 30 and 50 (mean age of 40) 52% of the women and 47.7% of the men were African American |
To examine the role of a FH of premature MI on CVD risk factor burden, atherosclerosis, and risk awareness in young men and women Individuals who did not know or were unclear about their FH were considered has having no FH of premature MI Information about perceived lifetime risk of MI, tobacco use, and physical activity were collected by questionnaire CAC was measured with Imatron 150 XP scanners |
FH
|
Andersson et al., 2009 Sweden and Poland Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
2054 total participants 1,043 (624 females, 419 males) from Poland 1,011 (554 females, 457 males) from Sweden All participants were 50-years old |
To examine how a personal experience of illness and FH of CVD affect risk behavior FH, personal experience of illness and risk behavior (smoking and exercise habits, BMI) were self-report |
FH
|
Slattery et al., 2009 United States Baseline data from a prospective, observational study |
10,374 American Indian and Alaska Native people 6489 females Mean age of 39.9 (SD ± 14.4) for all participants |
To examine the prevalence of self-reported FH of heart attack and stroke among a cohort of American Indian and Alaska Native people To evaluate the association between having a positive FH among FDR and health behaviors Study measures: health and lifestyle questionnaire that included physical activity, medical conditions, and family health history Medical tests included BP, height, weight, and serum lipid and glucose levels |
FH
|
Acheson et al., 2010 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
2,330 participants completed the study questionnaires 71% were women and were 91% Caucasian Participants’ age ranged from 35–65 years (mean age of 50 years) |
To determining if FH was related to patients’ perceptions of risk, worry, and control over getting six diseases First, participants completed online questionnaires measured demographics, self-reported health status, personal risk factors, and health perceptions for each of the six diseases Secondly, the participants used the web-based Family Healthware questionnaire to record their detailed family medical history Based on the data collected, familial risk for each disease is summarized as weak (similar to general population risk), moderate (having one FDR with the disease), or strong (having more than one FDR with the disease) |
Participants rated their level of perceived risk for CHD as 2.71 (on a scale of 1–5), which corresponded to the response “about the same as average” Results were similar for stroke (2.65 on a scale of 1–5) The majority of people determined to be at increase risk for HD and stroke based on the Family Healthware algorithms did not consider themselves to be at increased risk For CHD, 30% of individual actually in the “moderate” and “strong” risk categories perceived their risk as being at above or much above the average risk For stroke, only 21% of the individuals in the “moderate” and “strong” categories perceived their risk as at above or much above the average risk |
Thompson et al., 2010 United Kingdom Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
103 family members of patient’s with premature CHD 57% females Median age of 41 Race/ethnicity not provided Participants from The Scottish Health Survey were used as the general population control group |
To compare the cardiovascular risk factors of family members of individuals with premature CHD to a general population control group Structured, nurse-administered questionnaires to collect data on demographic information, lifestyle cardiovascular risk factors and medical history; anthropometric measurements, resting BP, and fasting blood sample obtained |
Five family members (5%) had prevalent CHD A significantly higher percentage had an ASSIGN risk score >20% compared with the general population (13% vs. 2%; p<0.001) 37% of family members were aware they were at increased risk and only 50% had had their BP and serum cholesterol level checked in the previous three years Awareness of increased risk was higher among offspring (48%) than siblings (34%) |
Darlow et al., 2012 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
397 overweight or obese women based on self-reported weight and height Ages ranged from 18 to 80 (mean, 38.0; SD ± 13.4) 42.8% African American, 29.7% Hispanic, 27.5% Caucasian |
To investigate associations between weight perceptions and perceived risk for HD among overweight or obese women Study measures: demographic information, self-perceived weight status, degree to which weight was a health problem, perceived risk based on persons the same age and sex, health literacy |
Perceiving oneself as overweight (OR, 4.33; 95% CI, 1.26–14.86) and FH of HD (OR=2.25; 95% CI: 1.08–4.69) were associated with greater perceived risk for HD For respondents with a lower health literacy, perceiving oneself as overweight was associated with greater perceived risk for HD (OR=4.69; 95% CI: 1.02–21.62) |
Diaz et al., 2012 United States Cross-sectional, descriptive study |
183 Hispanic adults 51% female Mean age of 36 for females; mean age of 38 for males |
To examine and compare perceived versus actual risk for developing CVD in a Hispanic sample Study measures: demographic information, health status, health behaviors, Tool to Assess Likelihood of Fasting Glucose Impairment, Personal Heart Early Assessment Risk Tool, and perceived risk status |
14.8% of respondents underestimated their 10-year CHD risk Respondents with diagnosed hypertension (38.8% vs. 5.5; p<.001), high cholesterol (38.5% vs. 5.5%; p<.001) or a FH of heart attack (30% vs. 11.6%; p=.02) were more likely to underestimate their 10-year CHD risk Men were more likely to underestimate their risk for and CHD risk compared to women (26.1% men vs. 3.4% women; p<.001) |
Abbreviations: BP, blood pressure; BMI, body mass index; CAC, coronary artery calcification; CHD, coronary heart disease; CVD, cardiovascular disease; CI, confidence interval; FH, family history; FDR, first-degree-relative; HD, heart disease; HPB, health-promoting behavior; HPLP II, Health-Promoting Lifestyle Profile II; HDL, high-density lipoprotein; LDL, low-density lipoprotein; MI, myocardial infarction; OR, odds ratio; RCT, randomized control trial; SD, standard deviation