Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Apr 29.
Published in final edited form as: J Psychiatr Res. 2009 Mar 9;43(11):987–996. doi: 10.1016/j.jpsychires.2009.01.014

Table 2. Study Rationale and Major Findings.

Instrument Validation Studies

Non-clinical populations
(Cartmel & Moon, 1992) Validation of two physical activity measures with a diary measure. Strenuous activity was over-reported, and mild/moderate activity underreported.
(Reuben, Wong, Walsh, & Hays, 1995) High rate of return using postcard diary system. Validity of postcards in corresponding to actual health care utilization was high.
(Pols, Peeters, Kemper, & Collette, 1996) Validation of two physical activity questionnaires with diary measure as gold standard.
(Klumb & Baltes, 1999) Compared ESM and “yesterday interview” approaches and found considerable agreement. Self-care activities were better suited for frequencies, and other activities better captured by durecation.
(Stel et al., 2004) The LAPAQ, a physical activity questionnaire, showed acceptable correspondence with a 7-day diary measure of activity, supporting its validity

Clinical populations

(Johnson & Bytheway, 2001) Older adults consistently maintaining a medication regime Diaries difficult for some pts, producing sampling biases. Attenuation of diary entry detail over the course of study.
(Jacelon & Imperio, 2005) Community dwelling older adults living with chronic health problems Diaries designed to collect qualitative data on daily health activities, and respondents could choose audio taped, telephone, or written diaries.

Hypothesis Testing

Non-clinical populations

(Baltes, Wahl, & Schmid-Furstoss, 1990) Older adults time use most characterized by obligatory activities, performed in the mornings, and afternoons and evenings were mostly spent with leisure activities. Activity profiles identified which related to significant differences in functional health and personal control.
(Stoller, 1993) Larger number of symptoms reported in a diary measure related to more negative interpretation of symptoms, and the majority of the sample reported interference with desired activities.
(Visser, van der Horst, de Groot, Deurenberg, & van Staveren, 1995) Physical activity monitored in experimental respiration chamber – greater activity did not correspond to greater energy cost.
(H. Mollenkopf et al., 1997) Social network density predicted greater mobility outside of the house, and those living at home and with no kids were at risk for low frequency of outdoor mobility.
(Shapiro & Goldstein, 1998) Participants described their activities/social context at random intervals corresponding with blood pressure data collection. BP higher among strangers than family, controlling for activity level.
(Musil et al., 1998) Total of 61% of a larger sample agreed to participate. Analysis of health problems reported indicated that most problems were not illnesses.
(McConnell & Copestake, 1999) Physical activities tracked through diaries correlated with respiratory muscle strength, controlling age and physical characteristics.
(Fricke & Unsworth, 2001) Older community dwelling sample spent most of time at home and alone, and tasks rated most important were IADLs.
(Klumb, 2001) Intra-individual variability in engagement in everyday activities predicted by self-efficacy, and productive activities perceived as more difficult.
(Kamarck et al., 2002) Within-subjects variability in negative affect, social conflict, and decisional control were associated with cardiovascular activation.
(Bouisson & Swendsen, 2003) Time-lag analyses indicate greater routine corresponded with decreasing positive affect and increased negative affect, in contrast to previous study.
(Heidrun Mollenkopf et al., 2004) Environmental/structural conditions predict mobility out of house in a large sample of European seniors.
(Milligan, Bingley, & Gatrell, 2005) Diaries included mixed-methods approach to assess health status and health-related activities. No gender effects in participation or quantify of information obtained.
(Ong & Allaire, 2005) Moderational impact of positive emotion on the link between negative emotion and subsequent cardiovascular activation. Social connectedness a major contributor to positive emotion.
(Neupert, Almeida, Mroczek, & Spiro, 2006) Extension of laboratory-based assessment of stressors and memory to naturalistic setting. Days with stressful events corresponded to occurrence of memory failures.

Clinical populations

(Hnatiuk, 1991) Elderly widows The daily lives of a sample of elderly widows measured using experience sampling method were found to be a valid and reliable method.
(Brown et al., 1996) Spousally bereaved elderly, Low social rhythm stability and activity level not present in bereaved generally, except among those experiencing a major depressive episode.
(Skarborn & Nicki, 2000) Elderly persons who were retired and older persons who were not retired Used worry diary to validate global self-report worry scale. With longitudinal follow up,, post-retirement, older people worry less than pre retirement.
(Richard, Justus, & Kurlan, 2001) Patients with Parkinson's disease and motor fluctuations No consistent relationship between mood and motor fluctuation, in contrast to prior studies using alternate methodology
(Ong, Bergeman, & Bisconti, 2004) Recently bereaved older adult widows Daily positive emotions after bereavement reduced the relationship between stress and depression.
(Chepenik et al., 2006) Primary care patients with major depression and other depressive disorders Greater intra-individual variability in dysphoria in major depression than expected and attenuated impact of positive events on positive affect in depressed but not comparison subjects.
(Weintraub, Cary, Stern, Taraborelli, & Katz, 2006) Non-depressed males with Parkinson's Disease Lower baseline positive affect in PD, decreasing positive, and an adverse impact of PD symptoms on positive and negative affect. However, patients with PD do not demonstrate anhedonia in response to positive life events.
(Kleban, Lawton, Nesselroade, & Parmelee, 1992) Depressed and non-depressed old adults in a long-term care facility Total absence of negative affect was more common than continuous presence of negative affect, total absence of positive affect, or continuous presence of positive affect among residents in a long term care facility.

Treatment Studies

Non-clinical populations

(Safford & Baumel, 1994) Diary of memory lapses assessed pre and post-intervention, checklist of memory lapses developed through preliminary study.
(Leaf & Reuben, 1996) Daily walking activity used as outcome measure to assess adherence to lifestyle intervention; 95% of subjects were adherent.
(Furlan, Kallan, Have, Lucki, & Katz, 2004) Healthy elderly volunteers did not demonstrate affective blunting or intra-individual variability in affect associated with SSRIs
(Katz et al., 2005) Compared diaries to telephone assessments and found consistency. Metoclopramide and Naproxen differed in their impact on the relationship between events and affect

Clinical Populations

(Dubbert, Cooper, Kirchner, Meydrech, & Bilbrew, 2002) Primary care patients Adherence to walking program assess with diaries. Compliance with diaries was inconsistent due to subject burden.
(Focht, Ewing, Gauvin, & Rejeski, 2002) Older, overweight, or obese adults with knee osteoarthritis (OA) Diurnal variation in pain characterized as gradually increased throughout the day, peaking in the afternoon and thereafter decreasing. Acute exercise resulted in an increase in pain when compared with reports occurring at a similar time of the day on a non-exercise day and with reports with equivalent medication use and stress.
(Andersson, Porsaeus, Wiklund, Kaldo, & Larsen, 2005) Elderly people with tinnitus Diaries administered pre- and post-treatment to assess effect of behavioral intervention. Diaries showed more change than global measure
(Morales et al., 2006) Older volunteers with high normal/mildly elevated serum cholesterol Assessment of the effects on emotional experiencing of Simvastatin. Greater emotional sensitivity to negative events suggested an effect which diminished over the course of study.
(Basler, Bertalanffy, Quint, Wilke, & Wolf, 2007) Older adults with chronic low back pain RCT with diary-based measure of time spent in physical activity and functional activity measured as outcome, showing no effect of motivational program