Table 3.
Study | Patients | Type of biopsy | Number of biopsies/Period | Mortality 30 days (90 days) | Risk factors |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Utz et al., Eur Respir J 2001 |
IPF = 46 |
OLB 73% |
No of biopsies not described |
- 16.7% in total population |
- 4/10 had AE-IPF before SLB |
CTD-UIP = 14 |
VATS 27% |
1986-1995 |
- All IPF |
- Lower DLCO |
|
- 21.7% in IPF | |||||
Lettieri et al., Chest 2005 |
IPF = 42 |
OLB (no?) |
No of biopsies not described |
- 4.8% |
- Mechanical ventilation |
Non-IPF = 41 |
VATS (no?) |
1996-2002 |
(5/6%) |
- Immunologic treatment |
|
- No difference IPF vs non-IPF, VATS vs OLB | |||||
Tiitto et al., Chest 2005 |
IPF = 64 |
OLB n = 42 |
1 |
- OLB 5.3% |
- OLB |
CTD-UIP = 12 |
VATS n = 34 |
1973-2002 |
- VATS 0% |
||
Park et al., Eur J Cardio-Thorac Surg 2007 |
IPF = 140 |
OLB n = 50 |
2-3 |
- 4% |
- AE-IPF |
NSIP = 46 |
VATS n = 150 |
1990-2003 |
(8%) |
- DLCO < 50% |
|
COP = 14 | |||||
No ICU patients | |||||
Sigurdsson et al., Ann Thorac Surg 2009 |
UIP = 23 |
OLB n = 45 |
1: 70% |
- 3% |
- No data of different ILDs |
OP = 17 |
VATS n = 28 |
2: 20% |
(4%) |
||
NSIP = 6 |
1986-2007 |
- No difference OLB vs VATS |
|||
Others = 27 | |||||
Fibla et al., Int J Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 2012 |
IPF = 122 |
OLB 10% |
1: 16% |
VATS 9% |
- Age > 67 |
|
COP = 31 |
VATS 90% |
2: 64% |
OLB 10.6% |
- OLB |
|
RBILD = 16 |
|
3: 59% |
|
- Immunologic treatment |
|
NSIP = 13 |
|
4: 1% |
|
- No data of different ILDs |
|
Others = 114 |
|
2002-2009 |
|
|
6% in ICU |
Abbreviations:
AE-IPF acute exacerbation of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.
COP cryptogenic organizing pneumonia.
CTD-ILD connective tissue associated interstitial lung disease.
DLCO diffusion capacity.
ILD interstitial lung disease.
ICU intensive care unit.
IPF idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.
NSIP nonspecific interstitial pneumonia.
OLB open lung thoracotomy.
RBILD respiratory bronchiolitis and interstitial lung disease.
SLB surgical lung biopsy.
VATS video-assisted thoracoscopic operation.