Skip to main content
. 2013 Jan 18;12:7. doi: 10.1186/1475-9276-12-7

Table 2.

Intervention studies

First Author (year) Disability/ impairment Design Aims Level of Evidence TREND Scores Population Geographic Setting Intervention type Methods Indigenous involvement Recruitment Control group Language Content/components Duration Evaluation Key Findings Conclusions/recommendations Category
Ryan, B. (2006)
Hearing
Experiment; intervention
To investigate Indigenous Australian children's attitudes of peers wearing hearing aids
VI
13
60 Indigenous Australian children aged 5–12 years (mean age 9)
3 urban schools in Alice Springs
learning- based desensitization program
Experiment (photographs of Aboriginal people with and without hearing aids, attitudes surveyed, 20 min. educational intervention on benefits of hearing aids)
Community Consult
No info
Reverse ordered
English and Tiwi
discussion-based intervention was designed to encourage the participants to reduce stigma and negative attitudes towards people who wear hearing aids; demonstrations; An audio example; scenarios
10 minutes
Survey
Children had negative attitudes towards others with hearing aids; intervention had significant effect on attitudes
Children had more negative attitude towards peers with hearing aids; intervention had significant effect on attitudes; Potential for negative attitudes towards peers w/hearing aids to be changed via learning-based discussion aimed at reducing negative attitudes.
A
Strange, A. (2008)
Hearing
Experimental; intervention
Identify the negative stigmas attached to hearing aids, increase awareness of attitudes
VI
13
62 Indigenous adolescents boarding at high schools Alice Springs aged 12–18 (mean age 14)
Alice Springs
learning- based desensitization program
Experiment (photographs of Aboriginal people with and without hearing aids, attitudes surveyed, 20 min. educational intervention on benefits of hearing aids)
Community Consult
No info
Reverse ordered
English and Tiwi
discussion-based intervention was designed to encourage the participants to reduce stigma and negative attitudes towards people who wear hearing aids; demonstrations; An audio example; scenarios
20-30 minutes
Survey
greater visibility of the hearing aid, is associated with more negative attitudes by adolescents; intervention demonstrated some reduced stigma
Stigma and negative attitudes contribute to the low use of hearing aids in children; Need to develop appropriate strategies to decrease stigma and increase the use of amplification; appropriate attitude changing techniques interventions needed
A
Yonovitz, L. (2000)
Hearing
Intervention
Demonstrate link between hearing loss and low English literacy
VI
10.75
1,032 Indigenous students 4–22 years old representing 106 rural and remote communities
NT (Darwin and Alice Springs)
phonological awareness
Teacher in-service sessions; pre/post PA- EFL criterion- referenced, diagnostic tests
Not reported
No info
None
English
1)two-day workshops for each school for teachers and assistant; 2)provision of amplification systems and hearing aids; 3) ear, hearing, phonological awareness assessment; 4) reading, spelling assessment; (over 1 school year)
12 months
ear, hearing, phonological awareness, reading, and spelling assessments
Teacher training, hearing support services, screening, and phonological awareness intervention documented strong improvements in literacy and contributed to understanding relationship between ear disease and low literacy.
This intervention represents a feasible, adaptive program that can be used in combination with existing ESL curricula and should not cause interference with already published phonics programs.
S, I
Massie, R. (2004) Hearing Intervention Identify effects of sound-field amplification on communication in classrooms of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children VI 11 64 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students from 4 classrooms in two rural QLD schools Rural QLD communities amplification trial Classroom observation; teacher questionnaire; assessments, modified Environmental Communication Profile, Screening Identification for Targeting Educational Risk rating scale None reported No info None English amplification on/off conditions changed fortnightly 8 weeks Teacher survey, sensory assessments Sound-field amplification intervention encouraged the children to interact with teachers and peers in a proactive way. No clear or enforceable standards for classroom acoustics in Australia exist; amplification may provide rapid, cost effective part of solution to improving the classroom listening environment. S, I

Queensland (QLD); Category: (R-recognition/awareness; A-Access; S-Solutions; I-Intervention; Q-Sequelae/outcomes); Level of Evidence: I Evidence from a systematic review, meta-analysis of all relevant randomized control trials (RCT) (Strongest); II Evidence from at least one well-designed RCT; III Evidence from well-designed controlled trials without randomization; IV Evidence from well-designed case–control and cohort studies; V Evidence from systematic reviews of descriptive and qualitative studies; VI Evidence from single descriptive or qualitative study; VII Evidence from the opinion of authorities or expert committee reports (Weakest).