Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 May 1.
Published in final edited form as: Eur Respir J. 2012 Aug 16;41(5):1023–1030. doi: 10.1183/09031936.00077012

Table 4.

Relative Risk Models Predicting Resistance or Susceptibility to World Trade Center-Lung Injury

Analyte Cutpoint# Sample Fraction Relative Risk(95% CI)

Cases Controls Crude+ Adjusted §
RESISTANT Single Analyte MPO ≤105.26 31/68 31/124 2.37(1.26–4.44) 2.92(1.40–6.08)
sVCAM ≥1568.65 30/68 31/124 2.51(1.34–4.71) 2.26(1.10–4.64)

Multi-Analyte MPO ≤105.26 31/68 31/124 2.39(1.26–4.56) 2.89(1.37–6.10)
sVCAM ≥1568.65 30/68 31/124 2.53(1.34–4.82) 2.24(1.07–4.70)
      AUC 0.647(0.564–0.731) 0.830(0.774–0.887)

SUSCEPTIBLE Single Analyte CRP ≥2.45 58/66 85/124 3.33(1.45–7.63) 3.00(1.20–7.47)
MIP-4 ≥194.90 18/66 59/124 0.45(0.24–0.84) 0.37(0.18–0.77)
Apo AI ≥4220.87 33/66 30/124 3.13(1.66–5.91) 3.61(1.72–7.61)
Apo AII ≥1772.87 36/66 30/124 3.76(1.99–7.10) 4.04(1.94–8.40)
Apo CII ≥398.44 29/66 31/124 2.35(1.25–4.43) 2.69(1.29–5.62)
Apo CIII ≥1058.87 29/66 31/124 2.35(1.25–4.43) 2.71(1.29–5.70)
Apo E ≥268.71 33/66 31/124 3.00(1.60–5.64) 3.03(1.46–6.30)

Multi-Analyte Apo AII ≥1772.87 36/66 30/124 3.51(1.80–6.87) 3.85(1.79–8.26)
CRP ≥2.45 58/66 85/124 4.01(1.65–9.79) 3.93(1.43–10.79)
MIP-4 ≥194.90 18/66 59/124 0.33(0.16–0.66) 0.26(0.11–0.59)
      AUC 0.767(0.692–0.842) 0.858(0.796–0.919)
#

MIP-4, sVCAM, and MPO in ng/mL, CRP in mg/dL, Apolipoproteins in µg/mL

Cutpoints were based on the 75th percentile of the Controls for all analytes except MPO (25th percentile) and CRP ≥2.45

+

Crude represents the risk without adjusting for any confounders

§

Adjusted: age at 9/11, BMI at SPE, exposure group and pre-9/11 FEV1% Predicted

Abbreviation Dictionary: Area Under the Curve(AUC)