Skip to main content
. 2012 Dec 23;54(3):494–514. doi: 10.1093/jrr/rrs114

Table 1.

Content of the PIDE, sorted by publications

No. Author/year/ref. No. s.c.a Cell lines Cell typeb Cell cyclec Cell origind α/β (Gy) Ion species Irr. cond.e LET (keV/µm)f E (MeV/u)f Phot.g Remarksh
1 Chapman et al., 1977 [18] 13 V79 n s r 2.22 4He, 12C, 20Ne, 40Ar s 2.34–402.7 26.1–319.0 220 LET given
2 Chapman et al., 1978 [19] 9 V79, T1 n a, s h, r 2.17–3.80 12C s 12.16–74.99 26.1–319.0 220 LET given
3 Blakely et al., 1979 [20] 24 T1 n a r 2.13 12C, 20Ne, 40Ar m 11–419 10.7–389.0 220
4 Raju et al., 1991 [21] 5 CHO-10B, HS-23, C3H_10T1/2, V79, AG1522 n a r 4.33–20.0 4He m 121–136 0.65–0.8 Co
5 Goodhead et al., 1992 [22] 10 HeLa, HeLa S3, C3H 10 T1/2 n a h, r 5.39–30.0 1H, 4He m 20.27–23.915 1.16–8.8 250
6 Folkard et al., 1996 [23] 10 V79 n a r 2.71 1H, 2H, 3He, 4He, 12C, 16O m 10.1–105.8 0.465–3.66 240
7 Eguchi-Kasai et al., 1996 [24] 22 irs1, irs2, L5178Y, M10, LTA, SL3-147 n a r 0.06–31.1 4He, 12C, 20Ne m 18–327 3.1–123.2 200
8 Suzuki et al., 1997 [25] 7 HE20 n s h 0.67 20Ne m 63–335 14.3–120.3 Cs
9 Bettega et al., 1998 [26] 8 C3H 10T1/2 n a r 15.0 1H, 2H m 6.65–33.2 0.72–4.89 Co
10 Tsuboi et al., 1998 [27] 20 NB1RGB, ONS-76, A-172, U251MG, TK-1 n, t a h 0.13–6.89 12C m 20–105 17.4–144.0 Cs
11 Tsuchida et al., 1998 [28] 6 A172, TK1 t a h 2.23–2.98 12C m 20–80 24.1–144.0 Cs
12 Weyrather et al., 1999 [29] 21 V79, CHO-K1, xrs5 n a r 3.57–∞ 12C m 13.7–482.7 2.4–266.4 250 Corrected
13 Furusawa et al., 2000 [30] 138 V59, HSG, T1 n a h, r 0.52–9.2 3He, 12C, 20Ne m 18.5–654 1.27–131 200 Values for α and D10 given; Corrected
14 Suzuki et al., 2000 [31] 30 NB1RGB, HFL-III, LC-1sq, A-549, C32TG, Marcus, U-251MGKO, SK-MG-1, KNS-89, KS-1, A-172, ONS-76, KNS-60, Becker, T98G, SF126 n, t a h 0.59–21.3 12C m 13.3–77.1 25.1–271.2 200 Corrected
15 Belli et al., 2000 [32] 12 HF19, M10, SCC25, SQ20B n, t a h 7.65–∞ 1H m 7.7–33 0.69–5.24 Cs + Co
16 Tsuruoka et al., 2005 [33] 41 NB1RGB n a h 17.47 12C, 20Ne, 28Si, 56Fe m 13–400 19.5–500 200 Values for RBE10 given
17 Belli et al., 2008 [34] 37 HF19, M10, SCC25, SQ20B, V79 n, t a h, r 4.41–∞ 12C m, s 13–303 4.5–290 Cs + Co <LETD> given
18 Belli et al., 1998 [35] 6 V79 n a r 2.80 1H m 7.7–34.6 0.57–5.01 No X-ray energy given; Data in parts taken from Belli et al., 1993 [36]
19 Hall et al., 1977 [37] 3 V79 n a r 3.24 40Ar s 110.9–409.2 48–330 250 <LETD> given
20 Bird and Burki, 1975 [38] 6 V79 n a r 18.6 4He, 7Li, 11B, 12C, 20Ne, 40Ar m 19.1–2000 5.09–9.93 145 Low X-ray energy; X-ray curve taken from Sinclair and Morton, 1966 [39]
21 v. Neubeck, 2009 [40] 6 RAT-1, IEC-6 n, t a r 6.69–15.9 12C m 13.3–163 9.9–270 250
22 Perris et al., 1986 [41] 2 V79 n a r 25.5 1H m 6–12 3–7.4 Co
23 Bettega et al., 1983 [42] 3 EUE n a h 211 1H m 1.83–5.8 8–31 Co Photon data taken from Bettega et al., 1979 [43]
24 Cox et al., 1977 [44] 4 V79, HF19 n a h, r 5.52–∞ 4He m 20–68 1.9–8.8 250
25 Wouters et al., 1996 [45] 11 V79 n a r 2.73 1H s 2.33–6.23 6.8–22.8 250 <LETD> given
26 Combs et al., 2009 [46] 4 U87-MG, LN229 t a h 4.53–6.52 12C m, s 103–170 9.8–18 250 <LETD> given
27 Kitajima et al., 2010 [47] 10 SuSa, AT1OS n s h ∞ 12C m 24–200 35–450 150 Low X-ray energy; values for RBEα given
28 Blomquist et al., 1993 [48] 2 LS-147T, V79 n, t a h, r 3.65–∞ 1H s 4 11.6 Co <LETD> given
29 Yang et al., 1985 [49] 9 C3H 10T1/2 n a r 0.36–13.4 12C, 20Ne, 28Si, 56Fe, 238U m 10.5–2080 103–990 225 E and LET from remaining range
30 Miller et al., 1995 [50] 10 C3H 10T1/2 n a r 2.80 1H, 2H, 3He, 4He, 12C, 16O m 3.8–418 0.275–12.9 250
31 Czub et al., 2008 [51] 4 CHO n a r 8.5 12C, 20Ne m 438–1245 1.69-2.78 Co
32 Kamlah et al., 2011 [52] 1 A594 t a h 11.6 12C m 168 9.9 6 MV
33 Aoki et al., 2000 [53] 6 V79 n a r 7.95 12C m 13–237 6.4–283 200
34 Han et al., 1998 [54] 6 SHE n a r 13.7 12C, 26Si m 13–400 18.5–283 250
35 Hamada et al., 2010 [55] 8 H1299 t a h 0.95 12C, 20Ne, 26Si, 40Ar, 56Fe m 13–200 20–600 200
36 Claesson et al., 2011 [56] 6 V79 n a, s r 4.33–∞ 4He m 110 1.625 100 Low X-ray energy
37 Wedenberg et al., 2010 [57] 5 T1 n a h 9.00 4He m 25–165 0.46–6.8 250
38 Miller et al., 1990 [58] 1 C3H 10T1/2 n a h 2.80 2H m 40 0.55 Photon data taken from Miller, 1995 [50]
39 Tobias et al., 1980 [59] 2 V79 n s r 11.5–21.3 40Ar m 370 55 220 E and LET from remaining range
40 Cox and Masson, 1979 [60] 7 HF19 n a h ∞ 4He, 11B, 14N m 20–470 1.24–10.3 250
41 Ito et al., 2006 [61] 7 HL-60 t a h 4.78 12C, 26Si, 56Fe m 20–440 26–126 4 MV
42 Tilly et al., 1999 [62] 3 V79 n a r 3.73 4He, 14N m 6–165 14.4–39 Co
43 Thacker et al., 1979 [63] 6 V79 n a r 3.90 4He, 11B, 14N m 28–470 1.24–10.3 Co
44 Hirayama et al., 2009 [64] 5 V79 n a r 3.57 12C, 56Fe m 20–2106 16–416 200
45 Hirayama et al., 2005 [65] 1 CHO n a r 3.23 12C m 79.6 24 200
46 Curtis et al., 1982 [66] 28 R-1 t a r 2.26 12C, 20Ne, 40Ar s 11–750 19.5–428 225 <LETD> given
47 Boehrnsen et al., 2002 [67] 2 V79 n a r 2.50 12C m 27.5–153 10.2–92.5 6 MV
48 Fournier et al., 2001 [68] 4 AG1522B, PS1 n a h 13.5–25.6 12C, 48Ni m 16.6–2455 9.9–195 250
49 Wulf et al., 1985 [69] 106 B14FAF28, V79 n a r 11.7–14.3 12C, 16O, 40Ca, 40Ar, 48Ti, 56Fe, 58Ni, 84Kr, 132Xe, 142Nd, 208Pb, 238U m 150–15 800 0.1–400 Values for cross- sections given; photon parameters taken from Wulf, 1983 [70] and Kraft, 1987 [71]
50 Scholz, 2003 [72] 8 CHO, V79 n a r 3.58–11.4 12C, 16O, 20Ne, 238U m 13.3–16 500 5–396 Photon parameters adapted from Weyrather et al., 1999 [29]
51 Persson et al., 2002 [73] 3 AA t a h 0.98 10B m 40-160 6.6–36.6 Co
52 Yang and Tobias, 1984 [74] 2 C3H 10 T1/2 n a r 1.07–2.07 56Fe, 238U m 500–1900 300–960 225
53 Scholz et al., 1997 [10] 8 CHO n a r 6.43 12C, 16O m 13.5–265 11–395 250
54 Prise et al., 1990 [75] 4 V79 n a r 4.07 1H, 4He m 16.9–108 0.76–1.9 250
55 Terato et al., 2008 [76] 4 AA8 n a r 30.0 12C m 13–200 43–290 Co
56 Suzuki et al., 1996 [77] 8 HE n s h 0.66 12C m 22–230 6.6–126 Cs
57 Matsumoto et al., 2008 [78] 6 C32TG, Colo679, HMV-I, HMV-II, 92-1, MeWo t a h 3.29–68 12C s 50 43.4 200 <LETD> given
58 Mehnati et al., 2005 [79] 13 CHO n a r 11.65 12C, 20Ne, 40Ar, 56Fe m 20–2000 13–144 200
59 Stenerloew et al., 1995 [80] 10 HTh7, B16, IGR, V79, LS-174T, U-343MG, DU-145 n, t a h, r 0.91–∞ 4He, 14N s,m 40–125 3.82–20.3 Co Unclear if LET or <LETD> given
60 Okayasu et al., 2006 [81] 10 CHO, xrs6, xrs6-hamKu80, HFLIII, 180BR n a h, r 2.70–∞ 12C, 56Fe m 70–200 28.5–430 No X-ray energy given
61 Tsuboi et al., 2007 [82] 9 U87MG, TK1 n, t a h 2.31–6.25 12C m 20–80 24–144 Cs
62 Todd, 1975 [83] 10 ChangHL, M3-1 n a h, r 0.64– 10.42 7Li, 11B, 12C, 14N, 16O, 20Ne, 40Ar m 55–1940 5.3–7 50 Low X-ray energy
63 Hall et al., 1972 [84] 1 V79 n a r 41.1 4He m 106 1.3 210
64 Takahashi et al., 2000 [85] 8 A172, A172neo, A172mp53, TG98G t a h 0.14–0.92 4He, 12C s 70–156 0.51–28.5 150 Low X-ray energy; <LETD> given
65 Takahashi et al., 2004 [86] 12 H1299wtp53, H1299tp53, H1299tp53-null t a h 0.00–2.56 12C m 30–100 18.5–83 200
66 Matsuzaki et al., 1998 [87] 3 OCUB-M, CRL-1500, YMB-1 t a h 4.45–21.3 12C s 80 24 200 <LETD> given; corrected
67 Kronenberg et al., 2009 [88] 1 Aprt n a r ∞ 56Fe m 151.4 1000 150 Values for D0 given; low X-ray energy
68 Hamada et al., 2006 [89] 6 AG01522 n a h ∞ 4He, 12C, 20Ne, 40Ar m 16.2–1610 7–25.5 Co Values for D0 given
69 Zhou et al., 2006 [90] 1 V79 n a r 3.63 12C m 100 18.5 200
70 Jenner et al., 1993 [91] 1 V79 n a r 2.2 4He m 120 0.81 Co
71 Furusawa et al., 2002 [92] 2 V79 n a r 7.15–11.4 40Ar, 58Fe m 86–442 115–575 150 Low X-ray energy
72 Takahashi et al., 2001 [93] 8 SASmp53, SASneo t a h 3.77–10.0 12C m 30–150 11–83 150 Low X-ray energy
73 Bettega et al., 2005 [94] 5 AG1522 n a h ∞ 26Si, 48Ti, 56Fe m 56–442 200–1000 Co
74 Ibañez et al., 2009 [95] 3 B16-F0 t a r 2.17 1H, 6Li m 3.4–135 2.9–14.4 Cs
75 Hellweg et al., 2011 [96] 2 HEK n a h 2.55 13C m 33–73 28–72 150 Low X-ray energy
76 Napolitano et al., 1992 [97] 1 C3H 10T1/2 n s r 9.0 4He m 177 0.45 80 Low X-ray energy
77 Hill et al., 2004 [98] 7 V79-4, irs1, irs2, irs3, CHO-K1, xrs5 n a r 3.7–∞ 4He m 121 3.26 250

Notes: For each publication, the first author, along with the year of publication, as well as the number of survival curves taken into the PIDE are given. Furthermore, summarizing properties of the used cells and radiation qualities are provided.

a No. s.c. = number of survival curves described in the publication.

b cell type: n = normal, t = tumor.

c cell cycle: a = asynchronous, s = synchronized in a particular phase of cell cycle.

d cell origin: h = human, r = rodent.

e irradiation conditions: m = monoenergetic, s = within a spread out Bragg peak.

f values given in italics if not given in the publications.

g X-ray energy in kVp or photon energy in MV for clinical accelerators if this unit is given, or Co = 60Co and Cs = 137Cs source.

h If linear quadratic parameters are not directly taken from figures or tables or from accessible survival values, the procedure is outlined here. Correction: shifting of one determined LQ parameters if the other is smaller than 0. Also other comments are given in this column. For spread out Bragg peaks, the quantities LET and 〈LETD〉 refer to track and dose averaged LET values, respectively.