Table 4. Literature review summary of migraine treatment or investigation by rTMS.
Author (Year) | # of Subjects (Age Range) | Type of Migraine | Drug therapy details | rTMS Protocol [Therapeutic or Diagnostic] | Coil Position | MRI Navigation | Sham Method | Adverse Events details | Migraine Outcome Measure | #of Responders (% total) comments |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Brighina F, et al. (2004) | 6 (40–54) | 6 M | Yes Maintained medication with no change in dose(anticonvulsant, β-blockers, calcium channel-blocker, SSRI) |
[HF] 12 days of (10 trains (20 Hz × 2s w/30s ITI)) =400 pulses/day @ 90% MT [D]-[T] |
LDLPC defined as area 5cm anterior to MC for activation of FDI | No | Coil tilted 45° from the skull | None | Self-rating scale | NR rTMS had a significant long-lasting effect in reducing headache attack frequency, headache index, and the number of abortive pills. |
Clarke BM, et al. (2006) | 42 (30–53) | 32 M 10 A |
Yes Maintained medication with no change in dose. (analgesics, antiemetics) |
[LF] 1–3 days of (0.2 Hz × 5s) =2 pulses/day @ 30% or 50% MO [T] |
NR | No | None | Dizziness (n = 1) Drowsiness (n = 3) |
5- point Likert scale MASQ |
29(69%) improved with 1 trial 19(87%) improved with 2 trials 9(82%) improved with 3 trials |
O’Reardon JP, et al. (2007) | 2 (51–66) | 2 M | NR Both patients used varying pharmacologic methods of treating migraines, but no mention of use during trial, including anticonvulsants and analagesics. |
[HF] 30 days of (10 Hz × 5 mins) =3000 pulses. day @ 120% MT [T] |
LDLPC defined as area 5cm anterior to MC for activation of FDI | No | None | NR | Self-rating scale | 2(100%) |
Teepker M, et al. (2009) | 13 (20–63) | 6 M 7 A |
No | [LF] 5 days of (2 trains (1 Hz × 8.3 mins w/1 min ITI)) =1000 pulses/day @ 100% RMT [T] |
Vertex, method of locating stimulation site not specified. | No | Sham Coil | Drowsiness (n = 1) Amyostasia (n = 1) Irritability (n = 1) Phonophobia (n = 1) Vigorous dreams (n = 1) |
Self-reporting Self-rating scale |
NR Significant reduction in migraine occurrence with active rTMS. |
Lipton RB, et al. (2010) | 102 (27–50) | 37 VA 45 NVA Additional patient data missing. |
Yes Maintained medication with no change in dose (β-adrenergic antagonists, SSRI, calcium-channel blockers) |
[LF] 1 day of (0.03 Hz × variable time) =max 120 pulses/day @ MO NR [T] |
Occiput just below the occipital bone, location method not specified. | No | Sham Coil | Headache (n = 3) Migraine (n = 3) Sinusitis (n = 2) Optic neuritis (n = 1) Nausea (n = 1) |
Self-reporting Self-rating scale |
34(42.7%) |