Table 2.
Histological scoring system for (A) overall tissue evaluation, (B) subchondral bone evaluation, and (C) cartilage evaluation in rabbit osteochondral defects [17].
Score | |
---|---|
(a) Overall defect evaluation (throughout the entire defect depth) | |
1. Percent filling with newly formed tissue | |
100% | 3 |
>50% | 2 |
<50% | 1 |
0% | 0 |
2. Percent degradation of the implant | |
100% | 3 |
>50% | 2 |
<50% | 1 |
0% | 0 |
(b) Subchondral bone evaluation (within the bottom 2 mm of defect) | |
3. Percent filling with newly formed tissue | |
100% | 3 |
>50% | 2 |
<50% | 1 |
0% | 0 |
4. Subchondral bone morphology | |
Normal, trabecular bone | 4 |
Trabecular bone, with some compact bone | 3 |
Compact bone | 2 |
Compact bone and fibrous tissue | 1 |
Only fibrous tissue or no tissue | 0 |
5. Extent of new tissue bonding with adjacent bone | |
Complete on both edges | 3 |
Complete on one edge | 2 |
Partial on both edges | 1 |
Without continuity on either edge | 0 |
(C) Cartilage evaluation (within the upper 1 mm of defect) | |
6. Morphology of newly formed surface tissue | |
Exclusively articular cartilage | 4 |
Mainly hyaline cartilage | 3 |
Fibrocartilage (spherical morphology observed with ≥ 75% of cells) | 2 |
Only fibrous cartilage (spherical morphology observed with < 75% of cells) | 1 |
No tissue | 0 |
7.Thickness of newly formed cartilage | |
Similar to the surrounding cartilage | 3 |
Greater than the surrounding cartilage | 2 |
Less than the surrounding cartilage | 1 |
No cartilage | 0 |
8. Joint surface regularity | |
Smooth, intact surface | 3 |
Surface fissures (<25% of new surface thickness) | 2 |
Deep fissures (≥25% of new surface thickness) | 1 |
Complete disruption of the new surface | 0 |