Skip to main content
. 2012 Oct 23;25(6):657–666. doi: 10.1080/09540121.2012.733332

Table 3.

Advantages and disadvantages of contraception options in HIV (Trussell, 2007).

Method Advantages Disadvantagesa
Condoms (male) • STI/HIV protection • Partner cooperation needed
• Requires correct technique
• Inconvenient/may interfere with sexual intercourse
• Pregnancy prevention = 85%

Condoms (female) • STI/HIV protection
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Requires correct technique
• Inconvenient/may interfere with sexual intercourse
• Pregnancy prevention = 79%
• Price and availability

Oral contraceptive pill • Effective
• Less blood loss
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = 92%
• Drug-drug interactions
• Possibly increased viral shedding
• No STI/HIV protection

Patch, ring, injectable combination • Effective
• Less blood loss
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = patch: 92%; ring: 92%
• Drug-drug interactions?
• Lack of data
• Increased viral shedding?
• No STI/HIV protection

DMPA • Low maintenance
• Effective
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = 97%
• No STI/HIV protection
• Possibly increased risk of HIV acquisition

Copper intra-uterine device • Convenient
• Effective
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = 99.2%
• Blood loss
• Increased pelvic infection
• No STI/HIV protection

Levonorgestrel-releasing intra-uterine system (LNG-IUS) • Long lasting
• Convenient
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = 99.8%
• Blood loss
• No STI/HIV protection
• Minimal research available in HIV

Cervical barrier • Some STI protection
• Good contraceptive effectiveness if used correctly
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = 84%
• Increased urinary tract infections
• Requires correct technique
• No STI/HIV protection

Sterilisation • Low maintenance
• Effective
• Can be controlled by the woman
• Pregnancy prevention = 99.5%
• Irreversible
• Expensive
• Invasive
• No STI/HIV protection

STI, sexually transmitted infection; HIV, human immunodeficiency virus.

a

Pregnancy prevention: The percentage of women who did not experience an unintended pregnancy during the first year of typical use of contraception in the USA.