Table 1. Summary of recently completed and ongoing clinical trials.
| Vaccine | Description | Is it safe? | Latest completed clinical trials: (main findings) | Clinical trials active (a) or recruiting (r) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
ProstVac VF (PSA-TRICOM) |
Heterologous prime/multiple boosts vaccinia virus (PSA-CD54-CD58-CD80) – fowlpox virus (PSA-CD54-CD58-CD80) |
Yes19,20 |
●Phase II: Enhanced OS over control group by a median 8.5 mo21 ●Phase II: Enhanced OS compared with Halabi nomogram prediction22 |
●Phase III (r): Comparison of OS with or without GM-CSF (NCT01322490) ●Phase II (r): Comparison of disease progressions with flutamide and flutamide alone (NCT00450463) |
|
ProstVac VF + ipilimumab (nivolumab) |
ProstVac VF + dose-escalation trial of anti-CTLA4 antibody |
Yes*,23 |
Phase I: Safe and tolerable*,23 |
|
|
ProstVac VF/ProstVac VF-like + docetaxel |
ProstVac VF-like (rV-PSA + rV-CD80) prime/rF-PSA boost) |
Yes24 |
Phase II: Safe. Docetaxel does not inhibit vaccine specific T-lymphocyte responses24 |
|
|
Ad5-PSA |
PSA-encoding adenovirus 5– one administration with/without Gelfoam® (Phase I) and three administrations with Gelfoam® (Phase II) |
Yes25 |
Phase I: Safe. In Ad5-PSA/Gelfoam® group 77% of PCa patients had detectable anti-PSA T cells25 |
Phase II (r): Assessment of effect of Ad5-PSA on PSADT (NCT00583024 and NCT00583752) |
|
Sipuleucel-T |
Leukopheresed patients PBMCs transduced ex vivo with PAP-GM-CSF construct (PAP2024) an then reintroduced into patients |
Yes9,10 |
Phase III:IMPACT trial: Enhanced OS over placebo group by a median of 4.1 mo12 |
Phase II (a):NCT00715078a Phase II (a):NCT00715104b Phase II (a):NCT00901342c Phase IIIB (a):NCT00779402d Phase II (r):NCT01306890e Phase II (a):NCT01487863f Phase II (a):NCT01431391g |
|
GVAX-PCa |
Irradiated PCa cell lines, LNCaP and PC-3, that constitutively express GM-CSF – Prime/Boosts |
Yes26,27 |
Phase I/II (×2): Safe. Enhanced median survival (for high dose boosts) over radiotherapy and low dose boosts by 8.7 mo26 and 11.9 mo27 respectively |
|
|
GVAX-PCa + docetaxel |
GVAX-PCa + docetaxel compared with docetaxel alone in PCa patients with symptomatic metastatic CRPC |
No - imbalance in deaths in the combined treatment group28 |
Phase III: VITAL-2:† terminated due to safety concerns. |
|
|
GVAX-PCa + ipilimumab |
GVAX-PCa (described above) + dose-escalation trial anti-CTLA4 antibody |
Yes††,29 |
Phase I: Safe†† (up to 3 mg/kg ipilimumab safe and well tolerated) |
|
|
DNA-PAP |
Multiple intradermal vaccinations of rhGM-CSF with a plasmid (pTVG-HP) encoding PAP |
Yes30 |
Phase I/II: Safe. 7/22 patients had ≥2-fold increase in PSADT |
●Phase II (r): Comparison of GM-CSF ± DNA-PAP (NCT01341652) ●Phase II (a): Determine safety and immunogenicity (NCT00849121) |
|
DNA-PSA |
Multiple intradermal vaccinations of GM-CSF + IL-2 with a plasmid (pVAX) encoding PSA |
Yes31 |
Phase I: Safe. 2/3 patients (given high dose pVax/PSA) had significantly elevated levels of PSA-specific IFNγ+ T cells |
|
|
GMCI |
AdV-tk/anti-herpetic prodrug (GCV) prior to prostatectomy |
Yes32,33 |
Phase I–II: Significant influx of CD8+ T cells No improvement in patient prognoses34 |
|
| GMCI + RT | AdV-tk/anti-herpetic prodrug (GCV) prior to prostatectomy + RT | Yes74 |
Phase I/II: Safe. Good locoregional control but inadequate systemic control72 |
Phase III (r): Comparing disease-free survival: GMCI + RT vs. placebo (NCT01436968) |
Grade 3–4 side effects observed with 3–10 mg/kg ipilimumab (colitis and neutropenia); †Phase III trials (×2) with GVAX-PCa were terminated, as discussed in the main text; ††Hypophysitis and/or sarcoid alveolitis diagnosed in patients receiving 5 mg/kg ipilimumab; aAims to assess CD54 upregulation with varying fusion protein (PAP2024) concentrations; bAims to assess the immune response within prostate tissue following the neo-adjuvant administration of sipuleucel-T (prostatectomy specimens taken after sipuleucel-T vaccinations will be compared with tissue from the core biopsy specimen obtained prior to treatment); cAims to evaluate the magnitude of immune responses to sipuleucel-T in patients with metastatic prostate cancer; dAims to determine if sipuleucel-T is effective in early stage, non-metastatic prostate cancer patients (end-point: biochemical failure); eAims to quantify the risk of cerebrovascular events following sipuleucel-T therapy for all subjects with CRPC; fAims to evaluate the impact of concurrent or sequential administration of abiraterone acetate plus prednisone on product parameters of sipuleucel-T; gAims to evaluate immune responses in patients with non-metastatic prostate cancer when androgen deprivation therapy is started before or after sipuleucel-T. CRPC, castration-resistant prostate cancer; GCV, ganciclovir; GMCI, gene-mediated cytotoxic immunotherapy; GM-CSF, granulocyte macrophage colony-stimulating factor; IFNγ, interferon γ; IL-2, interleukin-2; OS, overall survival; PAP, prostate acid phosphatase; PBMC, peripheral blood mononuclear cell: PSA, prostate-specific antigen; PSADT, PDA doubling time; RT, radiotherapy.