Table 1. Mann-Whitney U statistical test applied to performance measures of models generated from Normal training datasets.
Datasets | PPI | NO-PPI | |
p-value | p-value | ||
C×C′ | Precision | 1.15E-04 | 2.43E-06 |
C×C′ | Recall | 3.51E-06 | 0.002 |
C×C′ | AUC | 1.73E-06 | 1.73E-06 |
C×F+C | Precision | 1.18E-11 | 1.61E-10 |
C×F+C | Recall | 5.36E-10 | 8.36E-12 |
C×F+C | AUC | 2.26E-11 | 2.26E-11 |
C×F′ | Precision | 8.41E-12 | 5.61E-10 |
C×F′ | Recall | 4.38E-09 | 0.000 |
C×F′ | AUC | 1.51E-09 | 1.51E-09 |
C×F′+C′ | Precision | 8.36E-12 | 1.61E-10 |
C×F′+C′ | Recall | 9.90E-10 | 7.21E-12 |
C×F′+C′ | AUC | 1.17E-10 | 1.17E-10 |
C′×F+C | Precision | 7.54E-12 | 2.17E-11 |
C′×F+C | Recall | 5.08E-11 | 0.000 |
C′×F+C | AUC | 7.46E-12 | 7.46E-12 |
C′×F′+C′ | Precision | 7.49E-12 | 1.49E-11 |
C′×F′+C′ | Recall | 2.76E-11 | 7.56E-12 |
C′×F′+C′ | AUC | 8.33E-12 | 8.33E-12 |
F+C×F′+C′ | Precision | 9.00E-04 | 1.76E-02 |
F+C×F′+C′ | Recall | *9.15E-02 | 0.002 |
F+C×F′+C′ | AUC | 2.46E-08 | 2.46E-08 |
F×C | Precision | 1.72E-11 | 2.11E-10 |
F×C | Recall | 7.28E-10 | 1.11E-11 |
F×C | AUC | 1.40E-10 | 1.40E-10 |
F×C′ | Precision | 7.49E-12 | 2.18E-11 |
F×C′ | Recall | 3.84E-11 | 0.000 |
F×C′ | AUC | 4.59E-11 | 4.59E-11 |
F×F+C | Precision | *2.49E-01 | *8.91E-02 |
F×F+C | Recall | *1.27E-01 | *2.79E-01 |
F×F+C | AUC | *1.34E-01 | *1.34E-01 |
F×F′ | Precision | 6.91E-04 | 1.61E-02 |
F×F′ | Recall | *7.23E-02 | 0.001 |
F×F′ | AUC | 4.62E-08 | 4.62E-08 |
F×F′+C′ | Precision | 1.25E-02 | *1.97E-01 |
F×F′+C′ | Recall | *4.14E-01 | 1.61E-02 |
F×F′+C′ | AUC | 4.67E-06 | 4.67E-06 |
F′×C′ | Precision | 7.54E-12 | 1.11E-10 |
F′×C′ | Recall | 1.40E-10 | 0.000 |
F′×C′ | AUC | 1.16E-10 | 1.16E-10 |
F′×F+C | Precision | 3.14E-05 | 2.31E-04 |
F′×F+C | Recall | 2.86E-03 | 1.50E-04 |
F′×F+C | AUC | 4.57E-10 | 4.57E-10 |
F′×F′+C′ | Precision | *9.50E-02 | *9.49E-02 |
F′×F′+C′ | Recall | *9.75E-02 | *0.162 |
F′×F′+C′ | AUC | 1.12E-02 | 1.12E-02 |
, no significant difference.