Table 1.
Methods for studying single molecule nucleosome structures and dynamics
Method | Advantages | Limits | |
---|---|---|---|
Fluorescence | Fluorescence methods in general | Low level of system perturbation High temporal resolution Native environment |
No control over system dynamics Limited fluorophore labeling strategies Artifacts due to fluorophores |
Single molecule FRET (smFRET) in general | No need for calibration for internal comparison (ratiometric measurement) High spatiotemporal resolution |
One-dimensional measurement | |
smFRET with surface-immobilized nucleosomes | Efficient to study detailed dynamics of a complex process with more than 2 states Easy to deconvolve heterogeneous populations (i.e. easy to filter out contaminants and inactive species) Limit of temporal resolution: with wide-field imaging: a few milliseconds with one point detection: tens to hundreds of microseconds (limited by photon emission rate) |
Possible effects of surface interactions with nucleosomes | |
smFRET and/or FCS with diffusing nucleosomes | No effects of surface interactions with nucleosomes FCS: Efficient to test if fast dynamics exist (tens to hundreds of microseconds) |
Impractical or impossible to study detailed dynamics of a complex process with more than 2 states Impractical or impossible to monitor dynamics with time scales longer than diffusion of nucleosomes |
|
Force | Force methods in general | Direct control of system dynamics Direct measure of interactions Native environment |
Low level of control over reaction coordinate High level of system perturbation Limited force-handle labeling strategies |
Optical tweezers | High force resolution (sub-pN) | Inefficient data collection (typically one molecule at a time) | |
Magnetic tweezers | Efficient data collection in a wide-field imaging setup (multiple molecules at a time) | Higher level of noise (i.e. limited precision in controlling and/or measuring force at a rate higher than a few Hz) | |
Scanning probe | Multi-dimensional imaging | Mostly under non-native conditions Typically very low or no temporal resolution |