Table 3.
Overview of reviews: quality and outcomes summary.
Review (first author, year) |
Primary outcome (as stated by review author or first listed) |
Quality rating of SRs (AMSTAR) |
Quality rating of evidence (grade) | SR authors' conclusions | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Very low | Low | Moderate | High | Insufficient data to assess | Positive effect | Negative effect | Unclear effect | |||
Aljasir, 2010 [8] | Management of type II diabetes | 10 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Anderson, 2011 [9] | Body mass index | 9.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Büssing, 2012 [10] | Pain (effect size) | 11 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Cabral, 2011 [11] | Treatment for psychiatric disorder | 11 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Dickinson, 2008 [12] | Blood pressure | 10.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Gerritsen, 2002 [13] | Pain (carpal tunnel syndrome) | 8.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Haaz, 2011 [14] | Clinical outcomes in arthritis | 6 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Heiwe, 2011 [15] | Muscular strength | 11 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Innes, 2007 [16] | Metabolic and anthropometric measures for diabetes mellitus | 9 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Innes, 2010 [17] | Menopausal symptoms | 6.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Kirkwood, 2005 [18] | Treatment for anxiety | 10 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Krisanaprakornkit, 2006 [19] | Treatment for clinical anxiety | 10.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Langhorst, 2012 [20] | Pain (fibromyalgia) | 10.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Lee, 2009 [21] | Menopausal symptoms | 11 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Lin, 2011 [22] | Quality of life for cancer patients | 10 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Mahendira, 2009 [23] | Effectiveness of treatment for osteoarthritis | 8.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Marc, 2011 [24] | Perceived stress | 11 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Morone, 2007 [25] | Pain (chronic in older adults) | 9.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Muller, 2004 [26] | Effectiveness of treatment for CTS | 10.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Pilkington, 2005 [27] | Treatment for depression | 7 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Posadzki, 2011 [28] | Pain (low back) | 10 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Ram, 2003 [29] | Asthma symptoms | 6 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Ramaratnam, 2000 [30] | Treatment for epilepsy | 11 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Slade, 2007 [31] | Pain (low back) | 5.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Smith, 2009 [32] | Psychological functioning of patients with cancer diagnosis | 10.5 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
Smith, 2011 [33] | Pain (labour) | 9 | ◆ | ◆ | ||||||
| ||||||||||
Total (average) | 9.4 | 3 | 13 | 1 | 0 | 9 | 11 | 0 | 15 |