Table 1. Summary of Recreated Original and Replication Analyses.
Study | Gene | Polymorphism | Outcome measures | Recreated originalP (dose × genotype ANOVA) | N (mixed/Caucasian) | ReplicationP (dose × genotype ANOVA) | N (mixed/Caucasian) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hohoff et al (2005)a | ADORA2A | rs5751876 | POMS Anxiety | 0.041 | 98 (M) | 0.624 | 281 (C) |
Lott et al (2005)a | SLC6A3 | 3′ UTR VNTR | DEQ Feel | 0.006 | 84 (M) | 0.597b | 273 (C) |
ARCI LSD | 0.007 | 86 (M) | 0.023b | 272 (C) | |||
Diastolic BP | 0.037 | 95 (M) | 0.581b | 284 (C) | |||
Flanagin et al (2006)a | BDNF | rs6265 (pooled) | POMS Arousal | 0.01 | 94 (M) | 0.862 | 276 (C) |
ARCI BG | 0.023 | 94 (M) | 0.543 | 278 (C) | |||
Heart rate | 0.023 | 94 (M) | 0.791 | 290 (C) | |||
Lott et al (2006)a | SLC6A4 | Intron 2 VNTR | ARCI MBG | 0.046 | 98 (M) | 0.352 | 279 (C) |
Veenstra-VanderWeele et al (2006)a | CSNK1E | rs135745 | DEQ Feel | 0.038 | 88 (M) | 0.267 | 279 (C) |
ARCI MBG | 0.008 | 89 (M) | 0.109 | 278 (C) | |||
Dlugos et al (2007)a | SLC6A2 | rs47958 | POMS positive mood | 0.019c | 90 (M) | 0.562c | 289 (C) |
POMS Elation | 0.01c | 90 (M) | 0.278c | 289 (C) | |||
Dlugos et al (2009) | SLC6A2 | rs36017 | POMS Elation (gender cov) | 0.154 | 156 (C) | 0.57 | 170 (C) |
POMS vigor | 0.041 | 156 (C) | 0.334b | 170 (C) | |||
SLC6A2 | rs1861647 | POMS Elation (gender cov) | 0.137 | 155 (C) | 0.875 | 170 (C) | |
POMS vigor | 0.006 | 155 (C) | 0.116b | 170 (C) | |||
Hamidovic et al (2009) | DRD2 | rs12364283 (pooled) | Stop RT | 0.008 | 89 (C) | 0.644b | 122 (C) |
Dlugos et al (2010) | FAAH | rs3766246 | POMS Arousal (gender cov) | 0.013 | 154 (C) | 0.123b | 173 (C) |
POMS fatigue | 0.009b | 155 (C) | 0.187b | 173 (C) | |||
FAAH | rs2295633 | POMS Arousal (gender cov) | 0.022 | 155 (C) | 0.369b | 173 (C) | |
POMS fatigue | 0.011 | 156 (C) | 0.478b | 173 (C) | |||
Hamidovic et al (2010a) | COMT | rs4680 | DSST | 0.008 | 149 (C) | 0.734 | 176 (C) |
Hamidovic et al (2010b) | SLC6A3 | rs460000 (pooled) | ARCI Amphetamine | 0.015 | 152 (C) | 0.03 | 169 (C) |
ARCI MBG | 0.025 | 152 (C) | 0.342b | 169 (C) | |||
Dlugos et al (2011) | OPRM1 | rs510769 | ARCI MBG | 0.031b | 162 (C) | 0.204b | 171 (C) |
ARCI A | 0.019b | 162 (C) | 0.571b | 171 (C) | |||
OPRM1 | rs2281617 (pooled) | ARCI MBG | 0.01b | 162 (C) | 0.340b | 171 (C) | |
ARCI BG (gender cov) | 0.008b | 162 (C) | 0.923b | 171 (C) |
P-values for primary tests in the recreated and replication samples are shown here. N denotes sample size. 'Mixed' refers to samples that include both Caucasians and non-Caucasians.
We were unable to locate the original genotype data files; therefore, we regenotyped subjects. However, because some DNA samples were unavailable, the sample size was smaller and therefore the values are slightly different from the initially published results.
Greenhouse–Gessier correction when Mauchly's Test of Sphericity P<0.05.
Kruskal–Wallis test.