Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Jun 7.
Published in final edited form as: Adm Policy Ment Health. 2008 Dec 23;36(2):83–90. doi: 10.1007/s10488-008-0198-3

Table 1.

Barriers to uptake of new psychological treatments

Barriers Rank Frequency Percent Examples
Clinician attitudes
Question efficacy in general 7 115 4.1 Being convinced that they are worth the effort to learn and have measurable positive outcomes
I need proof that it has been tried and is successful
Belief that psychotherapy is more than a set of techniques 21 26 0.9 I do not need techniques, they are not significant, the process is!
My belief that the most important curative aspect of treatment is the client/therapist relationship
Belief that what one is currently doing is sufficient/effective 8 95 3.4 I am very comfortable with what I do and believe that it provides me the foundation I need to do effective therapy
I have enough in my armamentarium and I do not find the need to add any
Belief that treatment must be compatible with therapist style/viewpoint 16.5 33 1.1 Finding ones that are compatible with the way I am comfortable practicing
It has to feel natural for me and consistent with my training and experience
Belief that treatment must be easily integrated with current approach 14 37 1.3 Difficulty integrating the new techniques/skills into my current approach in a systematic and meaningful way
How to integrate it into who I am, what I do
Lack of interest or energy/inertia/boredom 11 67 2.4 Boredom/burnout
My own energy and enthusiasm
Late age/stage in professional development 16.5 33 1.1 Do not want to learn complicated systems at this stage of my career
I am old and have been trained up the wazoo
Client attitudes/characteristics
Client’s resistance 12 57 2.0 Engaging the client to try something new and outside their comfort zone
Getting the client to be open to the new technique
Question efficacy or applicability for particular client population 9 75 2.6 An impoverished public mental health clientele whose lives are often in chaos and who need much practical assistance on an ongoing basis
Sufficient client base with relevant issues/interest to justify time and expense
Contextual or institutional factors
Institutional restrictions/lack of institutional support 6 116 4.1 Agency practices from a specific theoretical perspective so techniques must be consistent with that.
Limited time with clients, and the amount of non-therapy tasks that also have to be addressed
Insurance restrictions 10 69 2.4 Insurance demands on time and “accepted” models of treatment.
Number of sessions allowed by insurance companies
Acceptance or support by other outside influences (e.g., colleagues) 15 36 1.3 Attitudes of other clinicians
Professional associations not endorsing or not accepting these as valid without empirical research
Training issues
Insufficient time 1 795 28.1 Getting the training. It is expensive and time consuming and it is difficult to get away from my practice. Time away is time without pay, and the pay is low enough as it is!
High cost of training 2 430 15.2 A lack of training opportunities that are affordable
Financial support for training and supervision
Lack of accessible (local) training opportunities 5 201 7.1 Lack of available training in my area
Lack of convenient training opportunities
Insufficient or lack of training/supervision for refining skills 3 249 8.8 Lack of ongoing support for skill building
Lack of opportunity to practice them under sufficient supervision
Lack of experience, confidence, comfort or proficiency in using technique 4 204 7.2 Developing enough proficiency in a new area to feel comfortable in using the new techniques
Learning the new techniques successfully and completely, so these will come as naturally as the ones I already use
Lack of tools to assist learning 24 13 0.5 Finding the resources that lay out practical, usable curricula that can be easily adapted for different needs
Lack of good video demonstrations of exactly how to do a particular therapy
Awareness or exposure to new techniques and knowing which one to choose from 22 25 0.9 Determining which of the myriad of available techniques would be the most relevant and useful to my work
Discerning the most useful training
Other
Implementation requires meeting certain special requirements 19 30 1.1 Becoming certified
Lack of physical space needed for some techniques
Insufficient number of clients 23 20 0.7 Availability of clients
Not enough clients
Ethical and legal concerns 20 27 1.0 Potential for litigation
The test of time to insure they are not harmful
Isolation 18 31 1.1 Lacking peer professional support to keep update on new research findings
Having colleagues to interact with that are doing the same techniques (within a 60 miles radius)
Other 13 46 1.6 Transcending my own internal biases and assumptions.
Tedium or complexity of the approach
Total 2830 100.0