Table 6.
Setting | Method | Pts | CTRL | VF/VT (%) | Δt at admission | Δt vs CTRL | ROSC | Hospital admission | Survival all patients | Survival admitted pts | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Callaway [19] | OHCA | Cranial cooling | 22 | Y (NT) | 41 | -0.02°C/min | NS | IATH 33% CTRL 0% |
IATH 66% CTRL 15% |
IATH 0% CTRL 0% |
IATH 0% CTRL 0% |
Bruel [15] | OHCA | Cold iv fluids | 33 | N | 24 | - 2.1°C | NA | 61% | 61% | 12% | 20% |
Kämärainen [20] | OHCA | Cold iv fluids | 17 | N | 59 | -1.34°C | NA | 71% | 64% | 6% | 9% |
Castrén [16] | OHCA | Trans-nasal | 194 | Y (PATH) | 30 | -1.3°C (tymp) | -0.7°C (core) - 1.3°C (tymp) |
IATH 38% CTRL 43% |
IATH 36% CTRL 42% |
IATH 15% CTRL 13% |
IATH 44% CTRL 31% |
Garrett [18] | OHCA | Cold iv fluids | 542 | Y (NT) | 22 | NA | NA | IATH 37% CTRL 27% |
IATH 28% CTRL 23% |
IATH 13% CTRL 12% |
IATH 44% CTRL 51% |
Δt, difference in temperature; CTRL, control group; iv, intravenous; NA, not applicable/available; N, no; NS, not significant; NT, normothermia; OHCA, out-of-hospital cardiac arrest; PATH, conventional (post-arrest) hypothermia; Pts., patients; ROSC, return of spontaneous circulation; tymp, tympanic; VF, ventricular fibrillation; VT, ventricular tachycardia; Y, yes